Some NFL players flip a switch when they step onto the field. One moment, they’re helping old ladies cross the street; the next, they’re bulldozing quarterbacks, talking trash, or playing the role of the league’s biggest heel.
But when the game clock hits zero, some of the most notorious “villains” in football history turn out to be… well, kind of awesome. Here’s a list of ten players who were absolute menaces on the field but surprisingly likeable off it.
1. Ndamukong Suh
Suh made a name for himself with bone-crushing hits, a few infamous stomps, and a reputation that made offensive linemen lose sleep. But off the field, he’s a well-spoken, intelligent guy who invests heavily in real estate and philanthropy. He’s also been known to nerd out over finance, proving that even the NFL’s scariest defensive tackle can have a softer side.
2. Richard Sherman
The mouthpiece of the “Legion of Boom” and the guy who made Michael Crabtree’s life miserable with an all-time postgame rant, Sherman was a relentless competitor. But off the field, he’s a Stanford graduate who’s articulate, insightful, and a strong advocate for education. Also, surprisingly friendly when he’s not verbally dismantling opponents on national TV.
3. James Harrison
A human wrecking ball who played every snap like he had a personal vendetta against offensive players, Harrison was a terrifying presence on the field. Yet off the field, he’s a hilarious dad who shares workout videos that make you question your own gym efforts. Also, weirdly charming in interviews, even if he still looks like he could bench press a truck.
4. Steve Smith Sr.
If talking trash were a sport, Smith would have more rings than Tom Brady. He backed it up, too, laying out defenders with his sneaky physicality. But beyond the game, he’s a sharp-witted analyst who’s surprisingly wholesome when talking about his family. Also, his charity work is no joke—he’s heavily involved in helping at-risk youth.
5. Terrell Suggs
The Ravens’ resident sack artist and a certified chaos agent, Suggs was always in the middle of the action. Yet, off the field, he’s a huge movie buff who’s surprisingly low-key and fun-loving. Also, his teammates loved him, which is saying something considering his on-field antics.
6. Jalen Ramsey
An elite corner with an elite trash-talking game to match, Ramsey could get under any receiver’s skin. But off the field, he’s a funny and personable guy who keeps things real in interviews. Also, a devoted family man who somehow turns off the villain mode as soon as he leaves the stadium.
7. Bill Romanowski
A linebacker with zero chill, Romanowski was notorious for spitting on players and breaking his own teammates’ jaws. Basically, the definition of a “dirty player.” But surprisingly, he’s now introspective about his past and advocates for better player health and wellness. Also, he’s mellowed out—well, as much as someone like Romo can mellow out.
8. DeAngelo Hall
One of the chattiest corners in NFL history, Hall made sure you knew exactly what he thought of you. His duels with receivers were legendary. But off the field, he’s a charismatic football analyst with an easygoing personality. If only his opponents got this version of him instead of the one chirping in their ears for four quarters.
9. Cortland Finnegan
The definition of “annoying,” Finnegan got under the skin of just about every receiver he faced—including Andre Johnson, who actually fought him. But off the field, he’s a shockingly laid-back guy who’s all about family and good vibes. He even admitted to being a pest just to get under players’ skin. Mission accomplished.
Read More: The Most Notorious Hollywood Feuds
10. Philip Rivers
The king of trash talk—without ever swearing—Rivers was a fiery competitor who let defenses know exactly how he felt, all while slinging sidearm passes like a madman. But off the field, he’s a devoted family man with about 37 kids (okay, it’s nine, but still). Rivers is one of the most genuinely nice guys in football, even if he drove opposing teams crazy.
Read More: The 10 TV Villains Who Stole the Whole Show