The Quick Report

These Popular Phrases Have Shockingly Dark Backstories

Everyday language is full of phrases that seem innocent yet hide shockingly grim backstories. These expressions are so embedded in modern speech that their origins often go unnoticed. Let’s uncover the dark secrets behind 15 of these common phrases.

1. “Bite the Bullet”

Battlefield 1 / Graveyard Shift
Openverse

Today, this phrase means to endure something painful with courage. Its origin, however, is far less metaphorical. In times before anesthesia, soldiers undergoing surgery on the battlefield were told to bite down on a bullet to cope with the pain—because why not add dental trauma to the mix?

2. “Saved by the Bell”

Funeral
Photo by Fylkesarkivet i Vestland

Now it’s used when someone is rescued just in time, but its roots lie in the 19th century’s morbid fear of being buried alive. Safety coffins were equipped with bells so that anyone accidentally buried while unconscious could alert the living. Imagine waking up underground, ringing for dear life—a horror movie waiting to happen.

3. “Butter Someone Up”

sliced cheese on clear glass plate
Photo by Sorin Gheorghita

When you butter someone up, you’re flattering them to get what you want. This odd phrase comes from an ancient Indian custom where devotees threw balls of butter at statues of gods to seek their favor. Flattering deities with dairy? Smooth.

4. “Riding Shotgun”

woman riding on vehicle putting her head and right arm outside the window while travelling the road
Photo by averie woodard

These days, it’s all about calling dibs on the front seat, but in the Wild West, riding shotgun was no casual affair. The person in this seat carried a shotgun to fend off stagecoach bandits. Turns out, sitting up front was as much about firepower as legroom.

5. “Bury the Hatchet”

red and black axe on wood slab
Photo by Markus Spiske

Making peace is the modern meaning here, but the phrase originated with Native American tribes. During peace negotiations, weapons were literally buried to signify the end of conflict. A practical yet profound gesture—though hopefully no one forgot where they put the hatchet.

6. “Kick the Bucket”

gray steel bucket on brown wooden table
Photo by Lucas van Oort

Now a lighthearted euphemism for death, this phrase might trace back to a gruesome method of execution or suicide. The condemned person would stand on a bucket with a noose around their neck, then kick the bucket away. Suddenly, the phrase feels less whimsical.

7. “Pulling Someone’s Leg”

Close-up of a runner's shoe splashing through a puddle on a rainy day.
Photo by cottonbro studio

This playful phrase actually has criminal origins. Thieves in the 18th century would trip victims by pulling their legs, making them easier to rob. Next time someone “pulls your leg,” at least you’ll keep your wallet close.

8. “A Baker’s Dozen”

Whole Grain Bread
Image by Openverse

This extra-loaf tradition stems from medieval England when bakers added a 13th loaf to avoid severe punishment for shortchanging customers. These punishments could include hefty fines or public flogging. Apparently, 13 wasn’t unlucky for bakers—it was insurance.

9. “Cat Got Your Tongue?”

gray and black cat in shallow photography
Photo by Shubhankar Sharma

We use it to ask why someone’s silent, but its past is gruesome. It may originate from the practice of cutting out liars’ tongues and feeding them to cats. Next time someone says it, you might want to respond.

10. “Let the Cat Out of the Bag”

gray cat on brown textile
Photo by Ani Adigyozalyan

Spilling secrets has nothing to do with felines but rather with medieval market scams. Farmers would sell pigs in sacks, but sneaky ones might swap the pig for a less valuable cat. Unveiling the cat literally exposed the fraud.

11. “Burning the Midnight Oil”

A candle burns warmly on a wooden surface, creating a cozy and relaxing ambiance.
Photo by Pixabay

It’s a nice way of saying you’re working late, but in older times, it wasn’t always by choice. People often burned oil late into the night while doing grueling, low-paying work. The modern version feels tame compared to the exhausting reality.

Read More: 10 Surprising Facts About Our Feline Friends

12. “Go Cold Turkey”

a whole chicken on a plate with a sprig of rosemary
Photo by Hayley Ryczek

Quitting something abruptly sounds rough, but the phrase’s origins are even worse. It refers to the clammy, pale skin of withdrawal, resembling cold turkey meat. It’s a visual that makes quitting cold turkey sound even less appealing.

Read More: 20 Phrases You Didn’t Know Were Offensive Now 

13. “Under the Weather”

brown sailboat in beach under white sky
Photo by Austin Neill

Feeling sick? In the past, this phrase referred to sailors who, when unwell, were sent below deck to recover from bad weather. It’s a reminder that modern medicine beats rocking on stormy seas.

Read More: 15 TV Catchphrases From the 90s We’ll Never Forget

14. “Mad as a Hatter”

A whimsical Alice in Wonderland inspired scene with a Mad Hatter character at a tea party.
Photo by Criativa Pix Fotografia

A quirky way to describe eccentricities, this phrase comes from the 18th and 19th centuries when hatmakers used mercury in their craft. Prolonged exposure caused tremors, mood swings, and hallucinations—basically, the mad hatter stereotype.

Read More: 15 Gen Z Slang Terms You Should Know

15. “The Writing on the Wall”

Until debt tear us apart printed red brick wall at daytime
Photo by Alice Pasqual

Today it means an ominous sign, but it comes from the biblical Book of Daniel. A mysterious hand wrote on a wall, predicting the fall of a kingdom. Less a helpful heads-up and more a terrifying prophecy.

Read More: You Might Be the WORST Boss if You Say These Phrases