Some quarterbacks thrive under pressure. Others? Well, let’s just say they start seeing ghosts the second a defender gets within five yards.
This list is for the quarterbacks who looked like Pro Bowlers with a clean pocket but panicked like it was a fire drill the moment protection broke down. From happy feet to questionable decision-making, these guys made defensive coordinators look like geniuses every time the pass rush turned up the heat.
20. Carson Wentz
When everything was perfect, Wentz could sling it with the best of them. But if the protection broke down, he suddenly forgot what color jerseys his teammates were wearing.
19. Nick Foles
Foles was a system guy who needed time to operate, and chaos wasn’t part of the script. Once the pocket collapsed, so did the game plan.
18. Christian Ponder
Ponder had athleticism, but you wouldn’t know it when the blitz came. He looked like a deer in headlights more often than not.
17. Blaine Gabbert
Gabbert had all the tools until he got touched. Then it was dump-off city or a sack buffet.
16. Matt Cassel
Cassel had that one magical year in New England, but when things got dicey, his internal clock turned into a ticking time bomb. Pocket pressure turned him into a checkdown machine.
15. Mitchell Trubisky
Trubisky could make some nice throws in rhythm, but take away his rhythm, and things unraveled fast. Once the pocket collapsed, so did his confidence.
14. Kyle Boller
Boller had a rocket arm but no sense of timing under pressure. The minute the walls caved in, it was YOLO ball or nothing at all.
13. Joey Harrington
Detroit fans know this one too well. Harrington crumbled under duress like a stale cookie.
12. Mark Sanchez
Sanchez was already on thin ice, and pressure didn’t help. When the pocket broke down, bad decisions followed like clockwork.
11. David Carr
Carr might be the poster child for shellshock. After getting hit so often early in his career, he saw ghosts for the rest of it.
10. Sam Darnold
Speaking of ghosts, Darnold literally admitted to seeing them. Once the pressure hit, it was either a wild throw or a baffling turnover.
9. Blake Bortles
Bortles could scramble, but that didn’t mean he knew what to do once the chaos started. More often than not, the pocket collapsing led to a brain freeze.
8. Drew Lock
Lock loved to show off the arm, but not the awareness. Pressure made him look like he was playing with his eyes closed.
7. Brandon Weeden
Weeden had all the size and arm strength, but no answer for pressure. Once defenders got close, he turned into a statue or a turnover machine.
6. Jake Locker
Locker had mobility, but that didn’t translate to pocket presence. He had a habit of either running straight into sacks or air-mailing throws under pressure.
5. Geno Smith (Pre-Seahawks edition)
Before his resurgence in Seattle, Geno looked allergic to pressure. As soon as the pocket broke down, it was usually downhill from there.
4. Tim Tebow
Tebow could make miracles happen, sometimes, but not with a collapsing pocket. His mechanics went out the window the second things got messy.
3. Josh Freeman
Freeman looked like a franchise guy for a minute. But the moment protection broke down, so did everything else.
Read More: 10 Reasons Lamar Jackson Is Actually the Best NFL Quarterback
2. Zach Wilson
Wilson has the arm talent, sure. But when the pocket collapses, he spins in circles like he’s playing backyard football with no plan.
Read More: 15 Retired QBs Who’d Dominate with Modern NFL Playbooks
1. JaMarcus Russell
Russell had a cannon but zero instincts when the heat came. The pocket collapsed, and so did his entire understanding of how football worked.
Read More: 15 Pocket Passer QBs Who’d Dominate With Modern Protection Rules
