Quarterbacking in the NFL has never been more protected—or productive—than it is today. With defensive penalties stacked in favor of QBs and roughing the passer flags flying like confetti, we couldn’t help but imagine how some classic pocket passers might feast in the current game.
These 15 quarterbacks were already impressive in their day, but with today’s rules? They’d light up the scoreboard like it’s the Fourth of July. Here’s who would thrive the most if they got to wear a modern-day “do not touch” jersey.
15. Bernie Kosar
Kosar’s funky mechanics didn’t stop him from carving up defenses, and he’d have all day to throw in today’s game. Add his love for quarterbacks to the rulebook, and he’d be dissecting zones like a surgeon.
14. Vinny Testaverde
Testaverde had the size, the arm, and the patience—he just needed more protection. In the flag-happy 2020s, he’d have time to throw 60-yard bombs in his sleep.
13. Ken O’Brien
Often overshadowed, O’Brien was accurate and composed under pressure. Remove the pressure, and you’d be looking at a perennial Pro Bowler.
12. Chris Chandler
Chandler’s main issue was durability, not talent. Give him the current rules and a little bubble wrap, and he’s suddenly a weekly fantasy football hero.
11. Phil Simms
Simms was a tough dude who took a lot of hits in his day. Let him work from a clean pocket, and that Super Bowl MVP ceiling gets even higher.
10. Neil Lomax
Lomax had all the tools but kept getting beaten up behind shaky lines. He might finally get the national love his talent deserved in the current NFL.
9. Boomer Esiason
Boomer had the quick release and bold arm to thrive in any era. Remove the threat of late hits, and he’s throwing 5,000-yard seasons with ease.
8. Jim Everett
Everett was fearless until the hits caught up with him—literally. With today’s bodyguard-style rules, he’d never see the turf and could fully live up to his potential.
7. Jim Plunkett
Years of abuse behind bad offensive lines held back Plunkett’s career. Put him in the modern NFL, and he’s getting comeback stories and MVP buzz.
6. Marc Bulger
Bulger had the accuracy, the smarts, and the arm, but was constantly getting smacked around. If he had the same pocket protection QBs enjoy now, he’d be a stat-sheet monster.
5. Tony Eason
Eason looked like a rising star before he became a crash test dummy behind poor protection. Give him time and today’s safety-first rules; he’d torch defenses with surgical precision.
4. Drew Bledsoe
Bledsoe had the cannon arm and classic dropback game, but he played in a much rougher era. He’d be slinging 40 touchdowns a year in today’s game and barely breaking a sweat.
3. Dan Fouts
Fouts already put up massive numbers in an era when defenders could mug you. Add in modern-day rules, and he might throw for 6,000 yards just because he felt like it.
Read More: Ranking The 7 Most Underrated NFL QBs Of All Time
2. Dan Marino
Marino was already unfair with his lightning-quick release and insane arm talent. Now imagine him without fear of getting touched—good luck, defenses.
Read More: 15 NFL Stars Who Let Their Game Do the Talking
1. Troy Aikman
Aikman’s stats never told the whole story. If he got today’s protection and a pass-first playbook, he’d be talked about like Brady and Manning.
Read More: 15 Retired QBs Who’d Dominate with Modern NFL Playbooks
