Patrick Mahomes is a magician on the football field. He throws no-look passes, scrambles like he’s in a video game, and already has multiple Super Bowl rings. But the GOAT? We’re not so sure.
And after that terrible performance in Super Bowl LIX?! Let’s pump the brakes a little. Yes, he’s amazing, but there are a few reasons why Mahomes will never be the Greatest of All Time. Let’s break it down:
1. Tom Brady’s Unmatched Super Bowl Record
Patrick Mahomes’ Super Bowl record pales in comparison to Tom Brady’s. With Brady’s seven Super Bowl victories, Mahomes’ three rings seem insignificant. Even if Mahomes continues to win championships, reaching Brady’s level seems nearly impossible.
2. Inconsistent Regular Season Performance
The 2024 NFL season exposed some of Mahomes’ weaknesses. He struggled with accuracy and decision-making, throwing more interceptions than touchdowns in the first half of the season. This inconsistency raises questions about his ability to maintain elite performance over a long career.
3. Vulnerability Under Pressure
Super Bowl LIX demonstrated Mahomes’ vulnerability when facing intense defensive pressure. The Philadelphia Eagles’ defensive line dominated, resulting in Mahomes being sacked a career-high six times. This weakness could be exploited by future opponents in crucial games.
4. Reliance on Elite Supporting Cast
Mahomes’ success is partly attributed to having exceptional teammates like Travis Kelce and an innovative coach in Andy Reid. His ability to perform at an elite level without these key figures remains unproven.
5. Limited MVP Awards
While Mahomes has won two NFL MVP awards, he still trails other quarterbacks in this category. To be considered the GOAT, he would need to consistently outperform his peers and rack up more individual accolades.
6. Lack of Longevity
At 29 years old, Mahomes has yet to prove he can maintain his high level of play for an extended period. Brady’s longevity, playing at an elite level well into his 40s, sets a bar that Mahomes may struggle to reach.
Read More: 10 Reasons Jayden Daniels Is the Next Patrick Mahomes
7. Questionable In-Game Decision Making
Mahomes has been criticized for occasionally making poor decisions under pressure, such as forcing throws into tight coverage or taking unnecessary risks. These lapses in judgment could cost his team in crucial moments.
Read More: 10 Reasons Why the Kansas City Chiefs Are the Most Hated Team in the NFL
8. Overreliance on Improvisation
While Mahomes’ ability to make plays outside the pocket is impressive, it may not be sustainable long-term. As he ages and loses mobility, his effectiveness could diminish if he can’t adapt to a more traditional playing style.
Read More: 10 Reasons Why Patrick Mahomes Is the GOAT
9. Struggles in Big Games
Despite his overall success, Mahomes has had notable struggles in some high-profile matchups. His performance in Super Bowl LV against Tampa Bay, where he failed to score a touchdown, still haunts him. And his performance in Super Bowl LIX? Down right terrible. These setbacks in crucial games could tarnish his legacy.
Read More: 10 Reasons Patrick Mahomes Is Better Than Tom Brady
10. The Evolving Nature of the NFL
The NFL is constantly changing, with new talented quarterbacks emerging each year. Mahomes will need to continually adapt and improve to stay ahead of the competition, a challenge that becomes increasingly difficult as his career progresses.
Watch Now: Big plays. Fast takes. Check out TQR Shorts for the latest sports news with Zoe!