Some NFL players blow their first opportunity and somehow bounce back for another. Others? Not so lucky. These guys never got that elusive second chance, whether due to bad timing, off-field trouble, or getting stuck in the wrong situation.
This list isn’t about one-hit wonders or washed-up veterans—it’s about the players who had talent, promise, or hype, but for one reason or another, never found themselves back on the field once their first shot fizzled out. Let’s count down the NFL stars who didn’t get that do-over they maybe deserved.
17. Johnny Manziel
The hype was sky-high, the swagger was real, and the flameout was fast. Johnny Football never got the NFL redemption arc his college fame hinted at.
16. Marcus Vick
Michael’s younger brother had flashes of promise, but off-field problems and a lack of patience from the league meant his NFL career ended almost as fast as it started. He’s been more of a trivia answer than a comeback story ever since.
15. Lawrence Phillips
He had first-round talent and off-the-field demons that couldn’t be ignored. The NFL gave up on him fast, and the rest of his story is more tragic than triumphant.
14. Justin Blackmon
![Jacksonville Jaguars wide receiver Justin Blackmon (14) is shoved out of bounds in the first quarter against the Cincinnati Bengals at EverBank Field in Jacksonville, FL on Sunday, September 30, 2012. [Bob Self/Florida Times-Union] Spt 02bsjagsvsbengal](https://thequickreport.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/Untitled-design-2025-06-02T210216.978-1024x658.png)
A top-5 pick with all the tools, Blackmon’s career was derailed by suspensions and legal trouble. Jacksonville never got their WR1, and no one else dared to try.
13. Ray Rice
One of the most productive backs of his era, Rice’s career ended instantly after a video surfaced of domestic violence. No team ever even entertained the idea of bringing him back.
12. David Boston
Once built like a linebacker playing wideout, Boston’s career went from dominant to nonexistent. No second shot, whether injuries, attitude, or off-field issues ever came.
11. Maurice Clarett
He tried to jump to the NFL early, fought the system, and finally got drafted. But nobody else came calling when things didn’t work out in Denver.
10. Art Schlichter
A first-round pick with serious gambling issues, Schlichter’s NFL career crumbled fast. Once he was out, there was no way back in.
9. Todd Marinovich
The original “Robo QB” was supposed to be built for NFL success. Instead, he fizzled out quickly and never got another look.
8. Antonio Bryant
At his best, he was a dynamic playmaker. But after a knee injury and a messy exit from Cincinnati, the comeback door slammed shut.
7. Charles Rogers
A top-10 pick with elite college production, Rogers couldn’t stay healthy or clean off the field. His career was over before it ever really began.
6. Kellen Winslow II
He had a solid run early in his career, but after injuries and legal troubles, the league moved on. His name is now more associated with headlines than highlights.
5. Ryan Leaf
One of the most infamous busts in league history, Leaf’s struggles were both mental and mechanical. No team wanted to see if he had changed.
4. Josh Freeman
Once seen as Tampa Bay’s franchise quarterback, Freeman’s drop-off was steep and sudden. After bouncing around briefly, the second chance never materialized.
3. JaMarcus Russell
Armed with a rocket arm and sky-high expectations, Russell never lived up to the hype. His lack of work ethic closed doors across the league.
Read More: 15 NFL Draft Picks That Set a Franchise Back Years
2. Rae Carruth
A talented receiver whose NFL career was derailed entirely by his involvement in a horrific crime. There was never a path back, and rightfully so.
Read More: The 30 Most Disliked Players in NFL History, Ranked
1. Colin Kaepernick
He led a team to the Super Bowl and had years of solid play, but once he knelt, the NFL seemed to shut the door collectively. His case became bigger than football, and that second chance never came.
