The NFL is full of teams that spark strong emotions, whether it’s love, hate, admiration, or sheer annoyance. Some franchises have a way of living rent-free in fans’ heads, thanks to their star players, historic success, or just their ability to always be part of the drama.
Whether it’s a team fans accuse of being overhyped, underperforming, or just flat-out annoying, these franchises tend to stir up the loudest debates. From Super Bowl dynasties to perennial underachievers with loyal followings, here are 15 of the most polarizing teams in the league today.
15. Minnesota Vikings
The Vikings have one of the most loyal fan bases and one of the most frustrating playoff histories. They’re always good enough to give fans hope, but rarely go far enough to justify the hype.
14. Cincinnati Bengals
For years, they were an afterthought, but their recent rise turned them into media darlings—and some fans aren’t thrilled about it. Joe Burrow is a star, but not everyone is buying into the Bengals as long-term contenders just yet.
13. Carolina Panthers
They’ve had flashes of relevance, but their identity always seems to be in flux. Some fans remember the Cam Newton era fondly, while others see the franchise as permanently stuck in reset mode.
12. Buffalo Bills
Everyone loves a good underdog story, and the Bills Mafia is iconic—but not everyone is convinced they’re as elite as advertised. The constant “this is their year” narrative can get old fast if they keep falling short.
11. New York Giants
They’ve won Super Bowls, sure, but they’ve also spent years looking completely lost. Depending on who you ask, they’re either a storied franchise with clutch history or a team coasting on past glory.
10. Atlanta Falcons
The Falcons’ highs have been high, but that Super Bowl collapse still haunts them—and it colors every conversation. Fans either feel bad for them or think they’re the ultimate choke artists.
9. Cleveland Browns
Few franchises have endured as much chaos, and yet they somehow still generate headlines. Whether it’s their quarterback drama or endless coaching changes, people can’t stop talking about them, for better or worse.
8. Green Bay Packers
They’ve had back-to-back Hall of Fame quarterbacks and tons of regular-season wins, but postseason letdowns still define recent years. Some fans idolize the franchise’s consistency, while others think it’s just been a whole lot of wasted potential.
7. New York Jets
They’ve been bad for so long, yet somehow stay in the spotlight. The endless quarterback sagas and bold offseason moves always spark debate, even when the team underperforms.
6. Dallas Cowboys
America’s Team or America’s Most Overrated Team? You either ride hard for the Cowboys or can’t wait to watch them implode every postseason.
5. Philadelphia Eagles
Eagles fans are intense, passionate, and loud—and not everyone loves that. The team’s recent success only added fuel to an already fiery national reaction.
4. Las Vegas Raiders
The silver and black brand is iconic, but the on-field product rarely matches the swagger. They’re a team of people who either romanticize or relentlessly mock.
3. San Francisco 49ers
The Niners are always in the mix, but their quarterback carousel and injury issues leave fans constantly divided. They’ve got talent and tradition, but not everyone believes in the hype year after year.
Read More: Ranking the Most Hated NBA Players of All Time
2. Pittsburgh Steelers
Their history is loaded with rings, but their recent play has been fine, not great. Some think they’re still elite just because they’re the Steelers, while others are ready to move on from the glory days.
Read More: Top 5 Most Polarizing Coaches in College Basketball History
1. New England Patriots
Nobody moves the needle quite like the Patriots. You either admired the dynasty or hated every second of it, and even post-Brady, the strong opinions haven’t gone anywhere.
Read More: 15 Most Polarizing Quarterbacks of the Modern Era
