Quarterbacks are supposed to be fearless leaders, but sometimes they’re just flat-out adorable. Whether it’s a charming smile or a personality that makes you melt, these QBs brought more than just touchdown passes to the table.
From throwback heartthrobs to modern-day cuties, this list celebrates the signal-callers who made us swoon just as much as they made us cheer. We’re not saying looks win games, but these guys definitely won our hearts.
25. Chad Pennington
With his kind eyes and clean-cut vibe, Pennington had serious “boy next door” energy. He looked like the guy who’d help you carry groceries, then casually throw for 250 yards.
24. Jimmy Clausen
He may not have had a long NFL career, but Jimmy’s perfectly tousled hair and California charm left a mark. He looked like a surfer who accidentally became a quarterback.
23. Colt McCoy
With a name like Colt and a Texas accent to match, McCoy had southern charm written all over him. He always looked like he had just finished praying and baking cookies for the team.
22. Teddy Bridgewater
Teddy’s soft smile and calm demeanor made him instantly likable. He radiates sweetness, like someone who gives really thoughtful birthday gifts.
21. Ken Dorsey
Dorsey had the look of a high school heartthrob who somehow ended up calling plays in the NFL. He was tall, chill, and always looked like he just woke up from a nap—in a cute way.
20. Baker Mayfield
There’s a cocky edge to Baker, but that mischief in his eyes makes it work. He gives off “class clown who wins prom king” vibes.
19. Kellen Moore
Kellen was always a little undersized for the NFL, which made him even more lovable. He had that dorky-cute energy you can’t help but root for.
18. Tony Romo
Romo’s relaxed smile and natural charisma made him a Dallas darling on and off the field. He looked like the guy who would beat you in golf and then insist on paying for lunch.
17. Russell Wilson
Russ has that polished, wholesome look that feels very rom-com lead. He’s like a guy who would pick your parents up from the airport without being asked.
16. CJ Stroud
CJ has a calm confidence and a smooth style that makes him instantly likable. He gives off “cool guy in your group project who actually does the work” energy.
15. Doug Flutie
Flutie’s small stature and scrappy charm made him an instant fan favorite. He looked like the underdog hero in every sports movie—and had the smile to match.
14. Brock Purdy
Brock has that golden retriever energy that just feels warm and dependable. His everyman charm and fresh-faced smile made him an instant fan favorite.
13. Matt Hasselbeck
Hasselbeck’s bald head and dad-joke face made him the NFL’s lovable uncle. He looked like he barbecues in cargo shorts and gives great advice.
12. Jordan Love
Jordan has smooth features and a quiet, gentle presence that gives him major heartthrob potential. He seems like the type who brings you flowers just because.
11. Trevor Lawrence
With flowing locks and the poise of a movie prince, Trevor was born to make people swoon. He looks like he could star in a Disney Channel Original Movie at any moment.
10. Tim Tebow
Tebow’s all-American looks and wholesome attitude were made for a Hallmark movie. He had the clean-cut charm of a youth group leader with a cannon for an arm.
9. Mark Sanchez
Sanchez’s thick hair and movie-star face made him one of the most photogenic QBs of his time. He could throw a spiral and light up a room in the same breath.
8. Aaron Rodgers (early years)
![Green Bay Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers (12)] celebrates during the Green Bay Packers 24-16 win over the Carolina Panthers in Green Bay, Wisconsin, Sunday, November 10, 2019. RICK WOOD/MILWAUKEE JOURNAL SENTINEL](https://thequickreport.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/USATSI_26243156_168418263_lowres-1024x968.jpg)
Before the beard and the darkness retreated, young Rodgers had a scruffy, mischievous charm. He looked like the fun friend who always brought snacks and sarcasm.
7. Tom Brady
Brady was the full package—jawline, dimples, and a supermodel wife to prove it. Whether you loved or hated him, you couldn’t deny the guy had serious dreamboat energy.
6. Jimmy Garoppolo
With a face made for magazine covers and a smile that could melt turf, Jimmy G’s simply unbeatable in the adorable department.
5. Justin Herbert
With his sleepy eyes and low-key demeanor, Herbert feels like a heartthrob who doesn’t know he’s a heartthrob. That humble vibe just adds to his cuteness.
4. Joe Burrow
Burrow has the swagger of a model and the smirk of someone who knows exactly what he’s doing. He gives off “cool guy who reads for fun” energy.
3. Jalen Hurts
Jalen’s quiet confidence and smooth smile have made him a modern-day NFL crush. He radiates calm, cool, and collected—like a guy who’s always five steps ahead.
Read more: 20 Golfers With the Most Infectious Smiles in the Game
2. Tua Tagovailoa
Tua’s soft-spoken charm and bright smile make him one of the most endearing QBs of the modern era. He’s got that “always texts back” energy.
Read more: Hottest NFL Quarterbacks of 2025: The Ultimate Ranking
1. Josh Allen
Allen’s farm-boy roots and big goofy grin are a winning combo. He looks like the sweet jock from a teen movie who secretly writes poetry.
Read more: 19 MLB Stars Who Cashed In Just For Being Cool
