Every baseball franchise has its “what if” moment—the one game, the one inning, the one pitch that lingers like a ghost. It doesn’t matter how good the roster was or how high the expectations soared—some playoff losses stick forever.
These teams had talent, momentum, and maybe even destiny on their side… until one postseason loss turned the vibe completely upside down. Here are 15 MLB teams that let one playoff loss define their era, from mildly soul-crushing to franchise-altering.
15. 2023 Atlanta Braves
After winning 104 games and looking like a juggernaut, the Braves got smoked by the Phillies in the NLDS. It was déjà vu all over again, and suddenly all that regular-season dominance didn’t feel so dominant.
14. 2012 Texas Rangers
Two straight trips to the World Series and then… a one-game Wild Card loss to the Orioles. That quick exit slammed the window shut on one of the most fun teams of the early 2010s.
13. 2001 Oakland A’s
The Moneyball A’s were primed for a run until Derek Jeter flipped the entire season with that play. After blowing a 2–0 lead to the Yankees in the ALDS, the narrative became clear: great regular season, not built for October.
12. 2017 Cleveland Indians
They won 22 straight games and looked like the team to beat—until the Yankees bounced them in the ALDS. That loss sucked all the momentum out of a squad that had been so close the year before.
11. 2019 Los Angeles Dodgers
Fresh off two straight World Series losses, the Dodgers were supposed to steamroll their way through October. Instead, they lost a wild Game 5 to the Nationals, and fans were left wondering if this core was cursed.
10. 2007 New York Mets
Yes, the collapse came in the regular season, but the loss to the Marlins on the final day was the dagger. That one game derailed a team built to win and cast a long shadow over the next few years.
9. 2008 Chicago Cubs
Back-to-back division titles had Cubs fans thinking this might be the year. Then they got swept by the Dodgers in the NLDS, and the curse talk crept right back in.
8. 1995 Seattle Mariners
Griffey, Edgar, and Randy Johnson finally broke through, but the loss to the Indians in the ALCS felt like the cap on their rise. It was fun while it lasted, but the team never made it back to that level.
7. 2015 Toronto Blue Jays
The bat flip heard ’round the world gave hope, but the ALCS loss to the Royals was a harsh reality check. After that, the core slowly broke apart, and the moment never came back.
6. 2003 Chicago Cubs
Five outs from the World Series, then came Bartman and a bullpen meltdown. That one game didn’t just end a season—it haunted an entire fanbase for more than a decade.
5. 1996 Cleveland Indians
They were loaded with stars, came off a 100-win season, and somehow lost to the Orioles in the ALDS. It was the moment people stopped fearing the mighty Tribe in October.
4. 1988 New York Mets
The 100-win Mets were heavy favorites to cruise past the Dodgers, but then Orel Hershiser and Mike Scioscia happened. That shocking NLCS loss broke the team’s confidence and started a quick downward spiral.
3. 2022 New York Mets
They won 101 games, talked all season about flipping the narrative, then lost a Wild Card series at home to the Padres. That weekend re-ignited every tired Mets joke and cast doubt on a wildly expensive roster.
Read More: Ranking the 17 Best MLB Players Right Now
2. 2006 New York Yankees
They had A-Rod, Jeter, Giambi, and Matsui, but couldn’t get past the Tigers in the ALDS. That loss kicked off years of postseason flameouts that made fans wonder if this team was all name, no game.
Read More: Ranking the 10 Most Frustrating MLB Teams to Root For
1. 2004 St. Louis Cardinals
A 105-win team with Albert Pujols and friends got utterly outclassed by the Red Sox in the World Series. That sweep didn’t just sting—it exposed how thin the gap really was between regular-season dominance and championship DNA.
Read More: The 15 Worst No. 1 Overall Picks in MLB Draft History
