Former Quarterbacks Who Could Still Play in the NFL

The NFL has seen some incredible talent under center over the years, and while most of the legends of the game have long retired, many of them still possess the skills to succeed in today’s modern game.

With the evolution of the passing game, the focus on athleticism, and the continued desire for dual-threat quarterbacks, some former quarterbacks, despite being out of the league, could still make a significant impact if they were to come out of retirement. Here are 15 former NFL quarterbacks who could still play in today’s game:

Boomer Esiason

Esiason was known for his accuracy and ability to lead his team to victories in big games. His quick release and precise throwing would make him a solid fit for today’s NFL, where quick throws and efficient offensive play are paramount.

Phil Simms

Phil Simms had the poise and skill to win Super Bowls, and his passing accuracy and football intelligence would transfer well to today’s game. His ability to manage the game and make smart decisions would make him a valuable asset in modern offenses, especially in teams that value a strong pocket passer.

Brett Favre

One of the most iconic quarterbacks of all time, Brett Favre retired in 2010 but could still perform in today’s NFL. Favre’s arm strength and ability to make any throw on the field would fit perfectly into the modern pass-heavy offense. His playmaking ability and leadership qualities would make him an asset for any team.

Drew Brees

Drew Brees retired in 2021 but, even in today’s more athletic and dynamic game, he would still be a top-tier quarterback. His accuracy and quick release made him a Hall of Famer, and those same traits would allow him to thrive in today’s quick-pass and spread offense.

Michael Vick

Vick was one of the first true dual-threat quarterbacks in the NFL, combining rare athleticism with a rocket arm. In today’s NFL, where mobile quarterbacks are highly valued, Vick would be a superstar, running read options and throwing deep balls with precision.

Steve Young

Steve Young was ahead of his time, excelling as both a passer and a rusher. His mobility, combined with a laser-sharp arm and the ability to read defenses, would make him an ideal quarterback in today’s hybrid offenses. Young’s ability to perform in the clutch would also make him a consistent winner in today’s NFL.

John Elway

John Elway was known for his powerful arm and ability to make throws into tight windows. His mobility in the pocket and ability to escape pressure would make him a dangerous weapon in today’s NFL, especially in offenses that emphasize improvisation and deep ball accuracy.

Peyton Manning

Though Manning retired in 2016, his football IQ and pinpoint accuracy would make him a force in today’s NFL. The league’s increased focus on precision passing and reading defenses would be right up Manning’s alley, and his ability to control the tempo of a game would still be elite.

Terry Bradshaw

Bradshaw’s strong arm and leadership abilities were the hallmark of his career. He was a key part of the Steelers’ dynasty in the 1970s, and while his style of play may seem old-fashioned, his ability to throw the deep ball with precision would still be an asset in today’s league, especially with the rise of high-octane passing attacks.

Kerry Collins

Kerry Collins was a steady quarterback throughout his career, known for his ability to read defenses and his consistency. His strong arm would make him a competent starter in today’s game, especially given the reliance on passing, and his calm demeanor would allow him to manage any offense effectively.

Jim Kelly

Kelly, a Hall of Famer, was one of the first quarterbacks to utilize a high-powered, fast-paced passing offense, making him an ideal fit for the pass-heavy systems in the NFL today. His decision-making and quick release would allow him to thrive in today’s game, particularly with how quarterbacks are coached to process information quickly.

Tom Brady

It’s hard to consider Brady retired after his retirement announcement in 2023, but the six-time Super Bowl champion’s longevity and competitiveness could easily allow him to continue playing at a high level in today’s NFL. Brady’s ability to read defenses and make quick, smart decisions remains one of the best in the history of the game.

Randall Cunningham

Cunningham was another trailblazer in terms of mobility for a quarterback. His speed and athleticism allowed him to extend plays, making him dangerous both with his arm and legs. In today’s NFL, where quarterbacks are often required to move in the pocket and create on the fly, Cunningham would be a perfect fit.

Chris Chandler

Chandler’s career was defined by his consistency and ability to run an offense efficiently. His strong arm, combined with his leadership and football IQ, would make him effective in today’s pass-first systems. While he wasn’t as flashy as some of his contemporaries, Chandler’s skill set would still allow him to thrive in the modern NFL.