The 1990s were a wild decade in baseball, full of power hitters, dominant pitchers, iconic moments, and a bit of controversy. Whether it was a home run chase, a nasty slider, or a glove that never missed, the ‘90s were stacked with stars who left their mark on the game.
From MVP winners to consistent All-Stars, these players defined the decade and became must-see TV. Here are the 20 best MLB stars of the ’90s, ranked by impact, production, and pure ‘90s baseball greatness.
20. Andres Galarraga
The Big Cat crushed baseballs and racked up RBIs like it was nothing. He was a feared power bat and a beloved clubhouse presence throughout the decade.
19. Frank Viola
Viola was a dependable ace and a big-game pitcher. He brought veteran poise and lefty dominance everywhere he went.
18. Roberto Alomar
Alomar was a slick-fielding second baseman with serious offensive skills. He made highlight-reel plays look routine and was a key piece on multiple playoff teams.
17. Mo Vaughn
Big Mo brought immense power to the Red Sox lineup. He won the 1995 AL MVP and was one of the toughest outs of the mid-’90s.
16. Albert Belle
Belle was intense, explosive, and one of the most feared hitters in baseball. He posted massive numbers year after year, even if he never smiled while doing it.
15. Fred McGriff
The Crime Dog was consistent and always dangerous at the plate. Quietly, he racked up over 280 home runs in the ’90s alone.
14. David Cone
Cone could flat-out deal and always showed up in the big moments. He was a strikeout machine, whether with the Mets, Blue Jays, or Yankees,
13. John Smoltz
Smoltz was part of the Braves’ legendary rotation and later became a dominant closer. No matter the role, he delivered.
12. Larry Walker
Walker combined power, average, and Gold Glove defense. He was a five-tool player who made it all look effortless.
11. Craig Biggio
Biggio did everything: hitting, stealing, taking pitches off the elbow, and playing multiple positions. He was the heartbeat of those gritty Astros teams.
10. Edgar Martinez
Edgar was a hitting savant and the ultimate professional at the plate. He practically invented the modern designated hitter mold.
9. Jeff Bagwell
Bagwell had the funky stance, but the numbers were no joke. He was an MVP, a slugger, and a key part of Houston’s rise in the ’90s.
8. Mike Mussina
Mussina quietly carved out a decade of excellence. He wasn’t flashy but bright, durable, and incredibly effective.
7. Ivan Rodriguez
Pudge had a rocket arm, a big bat, and leadership behind the plate. He was the complete package and a perennial All-Star.
6. Greg Maddux
Maddux didn’t overpower you—he outsmarted you. His control and efficiency were unmatched, and he owned the ‘90s with four straight Cy Youngs.
5. Barry Bonds
Before the controversy, Bonds was a complete player with power, speed, and a glove. He won three MVPs in the decade and made pitchers miserable.
4. Ken Griffey Jr.
Griffey was the face of the ’90s—smooth swing, big smile, and highlight-reel defense. The Kid made baseball cool and crushed over 350 homers in the decade.
3. Roger Clemens
Clemens reinvented himself in the ’90s and came back stronger than ever. He won multiple Cy Youngs and remained one of the game’s most intimidating presences.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Exciting MLB Players in the ’90s
2. Randy Johnson
The Big Unit was terrifying on the mound—tall, wild, and dominant. He struck out everyone in sight and anchored some of the decade’s best rotations.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Best First Basemen in MLB History
1. Cal Ripken Jr.
Ripken defined toughness, consistency, and professionalism. He broke Lou Gehrig’s record for consecutive games and was the ironman face of baseball in the ’90s.
Read More: The 15 Best Second Basemen in MLB History, Ranked
