Golf is a game of patience, precision, and longevity—but some players just couldn’t keep the momentum going. Whether it was early major success, a burst of hype, or a rise in the rankings, these golfers hit their high point way earlier than expected.
For some, it was injuries that derailed what looked like a promising run. For others, the spotlight came too quickly, and they never quite found their groove again. Here are 12 golfers who peaked too soon and never fully recaptured that early magic.
12. David Duval
Duval looked like Tiger’s main rival for a hot minute before fading into the background. Once a world No. 1, his game unraveled fast and never truly recovered.
11. Paula Creamer
She won the U.S. Women’s Open at 23 and looked poised to dominate for a decade. Instead, injuries and inconsistency kept her from building on that early success.
10. Anthony Kim
Kim was electric and flashy and had fans thinking he was golf’s next big superstar. Then he vanished from the game almost as quickly as he arrived.
9. Matteo Manassero
The Italian phenom won on the European Tour as a teenager and seemed destined for greatness. But his game collapsed in his 20s, and he’s been battling to find form ever since.
8. Yani Tseng
Tseng became the youngest player ever to win five majors, then abruptly fell off the map. Her drop-off was as stunning as her rise, leaving fans wondering what happened.
7. Ty Tryon
Tryon qualified for the PGA Tour at just 17, and the hype train was full steam ahead. Unfortunately, his pro career never lived up to the billing.
6. Michelle Wie
Wie was a teenage prodigy who competed with the men and captured the public’s imagination. She won a major later on, but the prime of her career felt like it came before she ever hit her stride.
5. Hunter Mahan
Mahan was a Ryder Cup staple and racked up wins in his 20s. Then his form nosedived, and he disappeared from leaderboards almost entirely.
4. Morgan Pressel
Pressel won a major at just 18, the youngest ever at the time. But instead of kicking off a dominant run, it ended up being the peak of her career.
3. Camilo Villegas
With a flashy game and fan-favorite charisma, Villegas looked like the real deal. He won a few early tournaments but never reached that elite level again.
Read more: 10 NFL Prospects Who Peaked at the Combine
2. Rickie Fowler
Fowler became the face of golf for a generation and contended in majors early on. But despite the endorsements and flair, the big-time wins have mostly eluded him.
Read more: 15 Golfers Who Took on WAY Too Many Sponsors
1. Jordan Spieth
Spieth won three majors by 24 and had the golf world in his hands. While he’s still relevant, that early dominance has proven tricky to replicate.
Read more: 14 Golfers Who Fell Off and Never Climbed Back
