10 NFL Prospects Who Peaked at the Combine

The NFL Combine is where draft dreams come alive — and sometimes where teams get a little too excited over a 40-yard dash. It’s where prospects shoot up boards with insane measurables, even when the game tape tells a different story.

While some players back up their Combine hype with solid careers, others see their stock soar and never quite live up to it. Here are 10 NFL prospects who peaked at the Combine and couldn’t carry that momentum into the pros.

10. Darrius Heyward-Bey

Darrius Heyward-Bey
Openverse

He blazed a 4.30 in the 40-yard dash and shot up draft boards. The Raiders fell in love with the speed, but his NFL career never hit that same gear.

9. Mike Mamula

Mike Mamula
Youtube | Philadelphia Eagles

Mamula trained specifically for Combine drills and crushed them. The Eagles bought in with a top-10 pick, but he never became the pass-rushing force they hoped for.

8. Vernon Gholston

Vernon Gholston
Youtube | AllProFootballData

Gholston showcased superhero-like size and strength at the Combine, convincing the Jets to draft him — but he failed to turn that raw ability into NFL production.

7. J.J. Arrington

J. J. Arrington
americasfirstchoice/ebay

Arrington was a combined standout and college star who wowed with his athleticism. But he struggled to find a consistent role once he hit the pros.

6. Troy Williamson

Troy Williamson
Youtube | Pro Football Weekly

He ran a blazing 40 and jumped off the charts in workouts. Minnesota banked on his athleticism, but it didn’t result in much on the field.

5. Bruce Campbell

Bruce Campbell
Youtube | Mario Bobino

Campbell’s Combine numbers were freakish for a lineman. That hype didn’t carry over into games, where consistency and technique were significant issues.

4. Matt Jones

Matt Jones
MikheSell/ebay

A college quarterback turned wide receiver, Jones lit up the Combine with size and speed. Jacksonville is a bit early, but he never quite adjusted to the new position at the pro level.

3. John Ross

Sgt. Scott Schmidt/Wikipedia

Ross broke the Combine 40-yard dash record and immediately shot up draft boards. Injuries and inconsistency kept him from ever living up to that top-10 pick hype.

2. Dri Archer

Dri Archer
Youtube | Neemias Queta burner

Archer ran one of the fastest 40s ever and looked like a human joystick in drills. But in the actual NFL? Defenses caught up to him real fast.

Read More: 10 Reasons Why the New York Yankees Are the Most Hated Team in Baseball

1. Zach Wilson

Zach Wilson
Openverse

Despite Wilson not participating in combine drills, he looked very sharp in scripted Pro Day throws that went viral, helping solidify his No. 2 overall pick status. But in real NFL action, the magic hasn’t quite shown up the same way.

Read More: The 20 Best NBA Duos Of All Time, Ranked

Related Articles
Jul 1, 2025; Wimbledon United Kingdom; Coco Gauff (USA) serves against Dayana Yastremska (UKR)(not pictured) on day 2 of The Championships, Wimbledon 2025 at All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club. Mandatory Credit: Geoff Burke-Imagn Images
Coco Gauff Refuses to Back Down For Her Political Stand
Fresh off her French Open win, Coco Gauff opens up about hope, representation, and why she’s unafraid...
Read More
Iowa Hawkeyes guard Caitlin Clark (22) takes questions after the NCAA Tournament championship basketball game at Rocket Mortgage Fieldhouse, Sunday, April 7, 2024 in Cleveland.
ESPN Analyst Reveals Why He Doesn't Get WNBA Tickets
It’s no secret that ESPN's Stephen A. Smith has never been shy with a hot take. But his recent defense...
Read More
UWGB men's basketball coach Doug Gottlieb walks off the court after his team's 72-70 loss to Michigan Tech on Dec. 18, 2024, at the Resch Center in Ashwaubenon.
Doug Gottlieb: 'The WNBA Is Not a Real Professional Sport'
Doug Gottlieb criticizes WNBA players’ treatment of Caitlin Clark, calling the league “not a real professional...
Read More

As an Amazon Associate, The Quick Report earns from qualifying purchases.

Part of the Castaway Studios media network.