Baseball may be a game of stats and strategy, but it’s also a game with some absolute goofballs. Over the years, some players have built reputations not only for their skills on the field but also for their wild antics, quirky superstitions, and moments of pure comedic genius.
From locker room pranksters to dugout dancers, these MLB stars brought as much entertainment off the field as they did on it. Whether they were intentionally silly or just couldn’t help themselves, here are the 20 silliest MLB players to ever step in the batter’s box.
20. Manny Ramirez
Manny being Manny wasn’t just a saying—it was a lifestyle. From disappearing into the Green Monster mid-game to high-fiving fans mid-play, he was chaos in cleats.
19. José Iglesias
Every team he’s on, he immediately becomes the clubhouse dance captain. The man treats dugouts like dancefloors and makes infield warmups look like a TikTok challenge.
18. Johnny Damon
Between the caveman beard and the carefree attitude, Damon always looked like he wandered out of a Renaissance Fair. He somehow made being an MLB leadoff hitter feel like a spring break event.
17. Nyjer Morgan
Whether he was playing under his alter ego “Tony Plush” or picking fights with entire rosters, Morgan was a walking sitcom. No one ever knew what he’d say—or throw—next.
16. Brandon Phillips
Always smiling and always stirring the pot, Phillips could turn a press conference into a stand-up routine. He once made more headlines for a pre-game handshake routine than his batting average.
15. Bartolo Colón
Big Sexy wasn’t just a nickname—it was an attitude. Between his unexpectedly iconic home run and his meme-worthy jogs to first base, he became a cult hero of silliness.
14. Yasiel Puig
Puig ran the bases like a toddler hyped up on sugar and fielded with the drama of a telenovela star. You could never accuse him of being boring.
13. Hunter Pence
With his gangly limbs, awkward running, and even weirder swing, Pence looked like a cartoon character playing baseball. And somehow, it worked beautifully.
12. Mark Fidrych
“The Bird” talked to the baseball, manicured the mound with his bare hands, and had full-blown conversations with himself. He was baseball’s answer to a one-man Broadway show.
11. Joe Maddon
Okay, technically a manager, but Maddon’s costume-filled clubhouses and themed road trips made him the MLB’s eccentric uncle. He once let players bring penguins into the locker room—because why not?
10. Kiké Hernández
Kiké treats every postgame interview like he’s auditioning for Saturday Night Live. His outfits, impressions, and energy make him the unofficial mayor of silliness.
9. Kevin Millar
Millar was the heartbeat of the Idiots-era Red Sox, cracking jokes and sipping shots before must-win games. He made even the tensest moments feel like a bachelor party.
8. Ozzie Guillen
Guillen’s press conferences alone deserve their own Netflix special. Whether he was yelling, laughing, or inventing new swear words, he never failed to entertain.
7. Elvis Andrus
He once pie-faced a teammate during a live interview and regularly started mid-game dance parties. Andrus made baseball feel like recess.
6. Turk Wendell
Wendell brushed his teeth between innings, wore a necklace of animal teeth, and hopped over the foul line like it was lava. He played like a man possessed by baseball spirits—and a little caffeine.
5. Nick Swisher
Swisher gave off human energy drink vibes 24/7. From air high-fives to shouting “Bro!” at anything that moved, he made MLB feel like a frat house in July.
4. Munenori Kawasaki
Kawasaki once stole the mic during a postgame interview just to shout about bananas. His English was shaky, but his comedic timing was elite.
3. Brian Wilson
Between the beard, the spandex tuxedo, and pretending to talk to imaginary people during interviews, Wilson was MLB’s answer to performance art. He pitched like a closer but lived like a stand-up comic.
2. Bill “Spaceman” Lee
Lee believed in aliens, threw eephus pitches, and once said he sprinkled marijuana on pancakes. He might’ve been a pretty good pitcher, but he was an even better weirdo.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Ruthless MLB Shortstops of All Time
1. Ichiro Suzuki
Quietly, one of the silliest legends ever, Ichiro’s serious face masked a prankster who once stole an interpreter’s pants and practiced his autograph on balls he planned to throw back to fans. His sense of humor was dry, subtle, and absolutely genius.
Read More: The 10 Silliest MLB Player Nicknames of All Time
