The 10 Worst Draft Picks in WNBA History

As we’re seeing this season with Caitlin Clark, drafting the right player can change the trajectory of a WNBA franchise forever. However, not every top pick fulfills the expectations set by their draft status. Whether it’s injuries, underperformance, or simply being outshined by their peers, here are the 10 worst draft picks in WNBA history.

Jacki Gemelos – Connecticut Sun (2012)

Openverse

Jacki Gemelos’ journey to the WNBA was derailed by a series of devastating knee injuries that kept her from ever playing for the Connecticut Sun. Sadly, her number-one pick status turned into a what-if story about unfulfilled potential and highlighted how injuries can drastically impact a player’s career.

LaToya Thomas – Cleveland Rockers (2003)

Robbie Faulk on YouTube

There’s no question LaToya Thomas was a star at Mississippi State, but she struggled to make a similar impact in the WNBA. Although she had a solid career, her performance was underwhelming for the number one overall pick.

Penny Toler – Miami Sol (2001)

Wikipedia

Known for her college scoring prowess at Long Beach State, Penny Toler never managed to translate her skills to the WNBA level. Unfortunately, Toler’s professional career was short-lived.

Megan Compain – Washington Mystics (2000)

Drafted with high hopes out of Stanford, Megan Compain found herself overwhelmed by the league’s physicality. Not to mention, her struggles with injuries and overall performance led her to leave the WNBA just a few years after her debut.

Dena Head – New York Liberty (1999)

Tennessee Athletics on YouTube

Dena Head’s collegiate success at Tennessee didn’t transfer to the WNBA, where she struggled with consistency. While she did have a few bright moments, her overall impact fell short of what the Liberty needed from a top pick.

Val Whiting – Phoenix Mercury (1997)

The Sports Deli on YouTube

Val Whiting entered the WNBA with high expectations, but her professional career was brief and underwhelming. Lacking the presence that defined her college days at Stanford, she could not make a significant mark in the league.

Kara Braxton – Detroit Shock (2005)

Openverse

Kara Braxton showed great potential, but off-the-court issues and an inability to stay focused on development left her unable to fulfill the expectations of a first-overall pick.

Read More: The Best Draft Picks in the History of the MLB

Ann Wauters – Cleveland Rockers (2000)

Openverse

The first international player to go number one, Ann Wauters never quite adjusted to the WNBA’s physicality or style of play. Despite a successful career overseas, she never reached her potential in the league.

Read More: The Most Memorable Moments in WNBA History

Janel McCarville – Charlotte Sting (2005)

Openverse

Janel McCarville struggled to find her rhythm in the WNBA, as injuries plagued her early years. Though she did eventually find success as a role player, her impact was not what Charlotte envisioned from their top pick.

Read More: The 20 Highest-Paid Players in the WNBA

Charli Collier – Dallas Wings (2021)

Openverse

Charli Collier was drafted with high hopes as a versatile big, but her professional career did not go as planned. In fact, she was waived by the Dallas Wings after just her second season in the WNBA.

Read More: The 20 Greatest Moments in WNBA History

Related Articles
New York Jets wide receiver Garrett Wilson (5) runs with the ball past Miami Dolphins cornerback Jalen Ramsey (5), Sunday January 5, 2025, in East Rutherford
Ranking the 15 Wide Receivers Who Could Explode in 2025–2026
From high-volume targets in revamped offenses to big-play threats waiting for their moment, these 15...
Read More
Jun 12, 2025; Berea, OH, USA; Cleveland Browns quarterback Dillon Gabriel (5) and quarterback Shedeur Sanders (12) during mini camp at CrossCountry Mortgage Campus. Mandatory Credit: Ken Blaze-Imagn Images
Browns' Rookie QBs Shedeur Sanders, Dillon Gabriel Face Uncertain Future Amid 2026 Draft Buzz
Shedeur Sanders and Dillon Gabriel could be short-term options as the Browns eye top quarterbacks in...
Read More
Oct 8, 2022; St. Louis, Missouri, USA; St. Louis Cardinals catcher Yadier Molina (4) walks off the field after hitting a single for his final postseason at bat in the ninth inning against the Philadelphia Phillies during game two of the Wild Card series for the 2022 MLB Playoffs at Busch Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jeff Curry-Imagn Images
Ranking the 15 Most Opinionated MLB Stars to Ever Play the Game
Whether clapping back at the media or speaking their mind about teammates, these players let their opinions...
Read More

As an Amazon Associate, The Quick Report earns from qualifying purchases.

Part of the Castaway Studios media network.