Top 15 Most Underrated NFL Stars

In the NFL, household names like Patrick Mahomes, Josh Allen, and Justin Jefferson often dominate headlines. However, behind the league’s superstars are a host of players whose contributions are equally impactful but often overlooked.

Whether it’s supporting superstars or quietly racking up impressive stats, here are the 15 most underrated players in the NFL today.

Andrew Van Ginkel 

Andrew Van Ginkel 
Openverse

Andrew Van Ginkel has been a playmaker for the Minnesota Vikings, recording multiple interceptions returned for touchdowns and being a key component of their defense.

Logan Hall

Logan Hall
Tampa Bay Buccaneers on YouTube

Logan Hall has been disruptive on the defensive line, recording multiple sacks and pressures, significantly impacting the Buccaneers’ pass rush.

Riley Moss 

Riley Moss
Wikipedia

Riley Moss has been effective in pass coverage, complementing a strong defensive backfield and contributing to the Broncos’ defensive successes.

Jared Goff

Jared Goff
Photo by All-Pro Reels

Jared Goff has led the Lions’ offense with precision, boasting an amazing completion rate and positioning himself in the MVP conversation, yet he often flies under the radar.

David Montgomery 

David Montgomery 
Openverse

David Montgomery’s physical running style and ability to gain tough yards make him a cornerstone of Detroit’s offense. Despite his consistency, he’s often overshadowed by flashier running backs.

Terry McLaurin

Terry McLaurin
Openverse

“Scary Terry” is one of the league’s most reliable receivers and has really shown his ability alongside rookie quarterback Jayden Daniels.

Matt Milano

Matt Milano
Openverse

Matt Milano’s versatility in coverage and run defense makes him one of the best linebackers in the game, yet he’s frequently overlooked.

Mike Hilton

Mike Hilton
Openverse

One of the best slot corners in the league, Mike Hilton’s physicality and knack for big plays are key to the Bengals’ defensive success.

Dallas Goedert

Dallas Goedert
Openverse

A crucial part of the Eagles’ offense, Dallas Goedert’s blocking and pass-catching prowess rival the league’s top tight ends.

Lavonte David

Lavonte David
Openverse

Lavonte David has been one of the most consistent linebackers for over a decade, but he remains in the shadows of more prominent names.

Trent McDuffie

Trent McDuffie
Openverse

Trent McDuffie’s ability to lock down receivers and provide reliable coverage has been a game-changer for the Chiefs, though he’s often overlooked in discussions about elite corners.

Trey McBride

Trey McBride
Wikipedia

Trey McBride has been a revelation in the Cardinals’ passing game, stepping up as one of the more reliable tight ends in the league this season.

Read More: The 11 Best Rivalries in the NFL

Zay Flowers 

Zay Flowers
Openverse

Zay Flowers has shown incredible promise, displaying elite separation ability and proving to be a dynamic playmaker for Lamar Jackson.

Read More: The 30 Most Insanely Overpaid Players in the NFL

Jakobi Meyers 

Jakobi Meyers 
Openverse

Jakobi Meyers has quietly put up strong numbers, excelling in contested catches and as a red-zone target.

Read More: The 10 Coldest Games Ever Played in the History of the NFL

Montez Sweat 

Montez Sweat 
Openverse

Montez Sweat has consistently been a game-wrecker throughout his career and knows how to make his presence felt in opposing backfields.

Read More: The NFL’s Highest-Paid Quarterbacks in 2024

Related Articles
Travis Kelce 2022 ESPY Awards
What Happens to the Chiefs After Travis Kelce?
The Kansas City Chiefs have built a modern dynasty on two pillars: Patrick Mahomes and Travis Kelce....
Read More
Cleveland Browns Stadium
'He’s Got That IT Factor': Tom Brady, Browns Stars React to Shedeur Sanders’ Draft
Shedeur Sanders’ draft slide was one of the biggest surprises of 2025. Expected to go much earlier, the...
Read More
Travis Kelce
Overrated Without Kelce? NFL Fans Debate Patrick Mahomes’ Legacy
Patrick Mahomes is already an NFL legend. He’s racked up two MVPs, three Super Bowl appearances, and...
Read More

As an Amazon Associate, The Quick Report earns from qualifying purchases.

Part of the Castaway Studios media network.