Why Tom Brady Will Always Be the Most Hated (and Respected) QB in History

Tom Brady is the NFL’s ultimate paradox—simultaneously the most hated and most respected quarterback to ever play the game.

Love him or loathe him, the GOAT left an undeniable mark on football. Here’s why he’ll forever be both despised and revered in equal measure.

1. Too Many Rings to Count

New England Patriots
Wikipedia

Haters will say it’s rigged, but the man has SEVEN Super Bowl rings. That’s more than any single franchise. Fans of other teams had to endure watching him hoist the Lombardi Trophy again… and again… and again.

2. The Tuck Rule Game

Tom Brady 
Openverse

Raiders fans have never recovered from the 2001 AFC Divisional Round. That infamous “Tuck Rule” call launched Brady’s dynasty and crushed the souls of Oakland faithful. Conspiracy theories still run wild.

3. Deflategate Drama

Tom Brady
Openverse

Accusations of underinflated footballs in the 2014 AFC Championship only fueled Brady hate. Was it cheating? Was it overblown? Either way, he served a four-game suspension and still came back to win the Super Bowl that season. Classic Brady.

4. 28-3: The Falcons’ Worst Nightmare

Tom Brady
Openverse

Falcons fans are still in therapy after watching Brady engineer the greatest Super Bowl comeback ever. Down 28-3, he led the Patriots to an overtime win, shattering Atlanta’s title dreams and cementing his villain status.

5. He Left New England… and Still Won

Tom Brady
Openverse

Patriots fans were heartbroken when Brady left for Tampa Bay in 2020. Then he went and won another Super Bowl—proving he didn’t need Bill Belichick. New England cried. The rest of the league sighed.

6. Ageless Wonder

Tom Brady
Wikipedia

Brady defied time, playing elite football into his 40s while other QBs his age were rocking dad bods on their couches. His avocado ice cream diet and TB12 Method kept him in MVP shape while making the rest of us feel bad about our life choices.

7. He’s Too Perfect

Tom Brady
Wikipedia

The guy has the looks, had the supermodel wife (Gisele Bündchen, at least for a while), and a net worth that makes our bank accounts weep. Plus, his social media game is annoyingly charming. It’s just not fair.

8. “We’re Onto Cincinnati”

Tom Brady
Wikipedia

Brady’s Patriot teams were cold, calculated, and annoyingly robotic. Whether it was a press conference deflection or their ability to ignore distractions, the New England dynasty crushed emotions and kept winning.

Read More: Every NFL MVP’s Season, Ranked From Worst to Best

9. The Ultimate Clutch Gene

Tom Brady
Wikipedia

Brady thrived under pressure like no other QB in history. Fourth-quarter comebacks, game-winning drives, last-minute dagger throws—he did it all. Opposing fans knew if Brady had the ball with two minutes left, the game was already over.

Read More: These Amazing NFL Players Left Money on the Field

10. Retired. Un-Retired. Retired Again.

Tom Brady
Wikipedia

Brady officially retired in 2022. Then came back. Then retired again in 2023—this time “for good.” NFL fans barely had time to process their emotions before he was back under center. Now, we all wait nervously to see if he pulls a Michael Jordan and returns again.

Read More: 10 Reasons Patrick Mahomes Is Better Than Tom Brady

Related Articles
Pete Rose
The 17 Most Pesky MLB Stars of All Time
Whether it was their relentless hustle or pesky plate approach, these 17 MLB stars made their careers...
Read More
Retired Pittsburgh Steelershead coach Bill Cowher is recognized at halftime of the Seattle Seahawks game for his induction into the Hall of Fame at Heinz Field.
The 13 Most Overrated NFL Coaches of All Time
From media darlings to guys who got too much credit for stacked rosters, we round up NFL coaches who’ve...
Read More
Jan 3, 2021; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Jalen Hurts (2) celebrates with teammates after a touchdown run against the Washington Football Team during the second quarter at Lincoln Financial Field. Mandatory Credit: Bill Streicher-Imagn Images
15 NFL Teams Everyone Secretly Loved to See Fail
For one reason or another, when these squads crash and burn, football fans everywhere can’t help but...
Read More
Carson Wentz
14 NFL Receivers With Hands Like Bricks
These NFL receivers were known for drops that made fans groan. Discover 14 wideouts with hands like bricks...
Read More
Dec 20, 2009; Dallas, TX, USA; Cleveland Cavaliers center Shaquille O'Neal (33) shoots a free throw against the Dallas Mavericks at American Airlines Arena. Mandatory Credit: Photo By Matthew Emmons-USA TODAY Sports
13 NBA Big Men Who Couldn’t Hit Free Throws
Whether it was nerves, mechanics, or just plain bad luck, these NBA big men turned every trip to the...
Read More
Dec 20, 2009; Denver, CO, USA; Oakland Raiders quarterback JaMarcus Russell (2) walks off the field after the Raiders' 20-19 victory over the Denver Broncos at Invesco Field. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee/Image of Sport-Imagn Images
12 Quarterbacks Who Had No Pocket Awareness
These 12 quarterbacks had all the tools—except pocket awareness. See who froze under pressure and made...
Read More

As an Amazon Associate, The Quick Report earns from qualifying purchases.

Part of the Castaway Studios media network.