Some tennis players explode onto the scene, capture the world’s attention, and then just… disappear. Whether it was injuries, pressure, or just plain bad luck, these stars seemed destined for greatness—until reality hit hard and fast.
They had the strokes, the swagger, and the wins to back it up, but for one reason or another, their time at the top didn’t last. These are the players who made noise early but couldn’t keep the momentum going for long.
16. Melanie Oudin
She shocked everyone with a magical run at the US Open and looked like America’s next great hope. But the spotlight faded almost as quickly as it arrived, and she never recaptured that spark.
15. Ernests Gulbis
For a hot second, Gulbis was the dangerous wildcard nobody wanted to face. Then came the inconsistency, the wild shot-making, and the long goodbye from relevance.
14. Laura Robson
She was hailed as the next big thing in British tennis, and early on, it seemed legit. But injuries and setbacks turned her promising career into a long what-could-have-been.
13. Donald Young
Young was hyped as the future of American men’s tennis before he could even vote. Unfortunately, that potential never fully materialized into big-time results.
12. Jelena Dokic
Her rise was fast and thrilling, complete with big wins and a lot of promise. But personal turmoil and injuries sent her career into a tailspin far too soon.
11. Bernard Tomic
Tomic’s game was flashy and his confidence was sky-high—but he often made more headlines for his antics than his tennis. He peaked early and then lost interest just as fast.
10. Nicole Vaidišová
She had the power, the look, and the ranking to match. But she walked away from tennis before her prime, leaving fans scratching their heads.
9. Ryan Harrison
Big serve, big forehand, and big expectations—Harrison had all the tools. But his climb stalled in the middle tiers, and he never quite broke through to the elite.
8. Anna Chakvetadze
She was a top-10 fixture with a smooth, strategic game that caught fire fast. Sadly, off-court struggles and injuries dimmed her flame far too early.
7. Jack Sock
He was fun, flashy, and briefly in the top 10 thanks to a breakout season. But his singles success never stuck, and he faded from the spotlight before many expected.
6. Alexandra Stevenson
Her Wimbledon semifinal run as a teenager had people buzzing. But consistent success never followed, and she gradually faded into obscurity.
5. Juan Martín del Potro
Yes, he won a Grand Slam—but injuries robbed him of what could have been a legendary career. He burned insanely bright and fought hard, but the body just wouldn’t cooperate.
4. Dinara Safina
She made it all the way to world No. 1 but never won a Slam, and the pressure got loud. Her decline came fast, and soon she was out of the game entirely.
Read More: 15 Tennis Players Who Treated Every Match Like a One-Person
3. David Nalbandian
He had the skills to hang with anyone and racked up some impressive wins. But he never quite hit that next level, and his brilliance always felt too fleeting.
Read More: The 15 Best Tennis Players Ruling the Court Right Now
2. Marion Bartoli
She shocked the world by winning Wimbledon, then retired not long after. It was a short, bright burst of tennis excellence that ended as suddenly as it began.
1. Gustavo Kuerten
Guga was a clay-court king with flair and charisma, climbing to world No. 1 in dramatic fashion. But injuries wrecked his rhythm, and the fall from the top was faster than anyone expected.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Boastful Tennis Players of All Time
