Let’s face it—every Major League Baseball fanbase thinks they know best. Whether it’s the endless debates about batting averages or the never-ending calls to fire the manager (when the team is three games above .500), every fan thinks they’re a self-proclaimed baseball genius.
But, let’s put that to the test and rank the 15 smartest MLB fanbases, based on a combination of passion, knowledge, and a little bit of common sense.
15. Pittsburgh Pirates
Pittsburgh fans have been through the ringer with the Pirates, but that doesn’t stop them from knowing their baseball. They’ve mastered the art of optimism in the face of mediocrity and can rattle off the minor league prospects they’re excited about with the precision of a scout. Plus, they know how to appreciate a strong bullpen, because that’s often all they’ve got to cheer for.
14. Chicago Cubs
Cubs fans are knowledgeable, but they’re also notoriously loyal. Some might say they’ve had enough time to study the game (106 years between championships, anyone?), so they know a thing or two about patience. Cubs fans will eagerly talk stats, but don’t be surprised if they slip in a “well, we still won the World Series in 2016!”
13. Boston Red Sox
There’s no shortage of knowledge in Red Sox Nation. Fans here understand the importance of sabermetrics, but they also know when to trust their gut. From the “idiots” of the 2004 World Series to the more analytical approaches of recent seasons, Red Sox fans are a mix of old-school wisdom and modern analytics.
12. New York Mets
Mets fans know baseball—just ask them. Whether it’s about the team’s complex history or their latest attempt to figure out how to utilize their starting rotation without everything going off the rails, Mets fans are always ready for an in-depth analysis. They’ve mastered the art of both cheering and sighing at the same time, and if you need to talk stats, they’ve got you covered.
11. Oakland Athletics
Oakland A’s fans have been the definition of “smart” for years, mainly because they’ve had to be. With one of the smallest budgets in baseball, these fans are all about finding value in overlooked players and exploring the numbers that make their team competitive despite financial constraints. They can tell you exactly why a no-name pitcher is going to have a breakout season—and they’re usually right.
10. Tampa Bay Rays
The Rays have built their fanbase on baseball intelligence. They’ve embraced the concept of “moneyball” long before it was cool, and Rays fans are always on top of new metrics and strategies. While they may not pack out the Trop, the ones who are there can talk WAR, OPS+, and launch angles like it’s their second language.
9. Cleveland Guardians
Guardians fans are cerebral, balancing their love for the game with a deep understanding of team-building and scouting. The fans here can discuss a player’s defensive metrics with the same fervor they reserve for a walk-off win. Cleveland might not always be the flashiest, but their fans know their stuff and appreciate the grind.
8. Atlanta Braves
Braves fans are sharp, no doubt about it. With a roster consistently stocked with talent, Braves fans have learned the value of knowing every statistic, from batting splits to defensive metrics. They’ll break down the impact of a trade or a signing with the precision of an analyst, and they’ll do it all while cracking open a cold one at Truist Park.
7. Los Angeles Dodgers
The Dodgers’ fanbase is large, diverse, and incredibly knowledgeable. From statistical breakdowns to pitch selection, Dodgers fans know the game inside and out. They can hold their own in any debate about who’s the greatest shortstop of all time or which rookie has the best potential. And they’re always aware of the latest trends, whether it’s a new pitch type or the coolest new way to approach analytics.
6. New York Yankees
Yankees fans might be known for their boastfulness (hey, they’ve earned it), but they’re also seriously smart when it comes to baseball. Their knowledge of historical stats is off the charts—ask any Yankees fan about the 27 championships and they’ll rattle off the most obscure details. They’re no slouches when it comes to modern-day stats either, and they can tell you why a 3-1 count is significant in any given at-bat.
5. San Francisco Giants
Giants fans know their stuff—and they’re always looking ahead. With the team’s focus on advanced analytics and their ability to adapt to trends, their fans are well-versed in both traditional metrics and sabermetrics. They don’t just watch the game—they study it, so expect a Giants fan to break down every nuance of a pitch sequence and explain why a late-game strategy worked.
4. St. Louis Cardinals
Cardinals fans are the definition of “smart baseball.” They’ve had a successful franchise for decades, and their fans have learned a lot from that. A true mix of tradition and analytics, Cardinals fans are adept at explaining how all the pieces fit together, from their legendary farm system to the crucial role of small-ball tactics. They’re also some of the most patient fans out there—after all, they know greatness takes time.
3. Toronto Blue Jays
Blue Jays fans are the intellectuals of the MLB world. With the combination of a thriving international fanbase and a roster full of young talent, they’re deeply entrenched in modern baseball thinking. They can break down an exit velocity and ISO like it’s a casual conversation and can go on for hours about how their team is building for the future. They understand the intricacies of the game and don’t just focus on the obvious.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Beloved MLB Franchises
2. Chicago White Sox
White Sox fans are passionate, and they know their numbers. They might not always have the history of other teams, but when it comes to understanding the metrics that matter, they’re ahead of the curve. From their focus on defense to an appreciation of advanced pitching stats, White Sox fans dig deep. If you want to talk modern baseball, they’ll give you an earful about the best analytics and how it applies to their team’s success.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Loyal MLB Fanbases
1. Minnesota Twins
Minnesota might surprise you as the top contender for the smartest fanbase, but here’s why: Twins fans live and breathe baseball in the most analytical way possible. They embrace the newest technologies, dissect every pitch, and have a keen eye for how their team’s advanced metrics can help them thrive. From their sabermetric-driven decisions to their constant knowledge about every player on the roster, Twins fans are baseball’s true intellectuals.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Hated MLB Fanbases