Ranking The Top 5 Most Clutch NHL Playoff Performers in History

The Stanley Cup Playoffs are where legacies are forged. The pace is faster, the hits are harder, and the pressure is off the charts. While some stars fade under the spotlight, others shine even brighter. These five players didn’t just perform, they delivered in the clutch, time and time again.

Let’s count down the Top 5 Most Clutch Playoff Performers in NHL History.

5. Patrick Roy

When the lights came on, Roy flipped the switch. He holds the all-time record for most playoff wins by a goalie and is the only netminder to win the Conn Smythe Trophy three times. Roy didn’t just win Cups, he stole them.

  • Career Playoff Stats: 151 wins, .918 save percentage, 2.30 GAA
  • Stanley Cups: 4 (1986, 1993, 1996, 2001)

4. Mark Messier

Messier’s clutch DNA is legendary, none more so than the 1994 Eastern Conference Finals, when he guaranteed a win in Game 6… then backed it up with a hat trick. He lifted not just teams, but cities.

  • Career Playoff Points: 295 in 236 games
  • Stanley Cups: 6

3. Sidney Crosby

Crosby’s playoff resume is packed with highlight-reel goals and clutch assists. He’s a two-time Conn Smythe winner and was the heartbeat of three Cup runs. His ability to stay composed while dragging his team forward puts him in elite company.

  • Career Playoff Points: 201 in 180 games
  • Stanley Cups: 3 (2009, 2016, 2017)

2. Wayne Gretzky

Yes, Gretzky’s entire career was ridiculous, but he was even more dangerous in the playoffs. His 47 points in the 1985 postseason remains the highest single-year total in NHL history. Clutch wasn’t just a moment for Wayne, it was a career.

  • Career Playoff Points: 382 in 208 games
  • Stanley Cups: 4 (1984–1988)

1. Claude Lemieux

He wasn’t the most skilled or most celebrated, but Claude Lemieux was built for the postseason. He consistently scored key goals and rattled opponents with his grit and edge. With a Conn Smythe Trophy and big goals for multiple franchises, he may be the most underrated clutch player ever.

  • Career Playoff Goals: 80 in 234 games
  • Stanley Cups: 4 (with 3 different teams)

Being clutch in the NHL playoffs takes more than skill, it takes ice in your veins and the will to win. Whether it was stopping pucks, leading comebacks, or sealing victories, these five NHL legends came through when it mattered most.

Related Articles
Jul 6, 2025; New York City, New York, USA; New York Yankees starting pitcher Max Fried (54) talks with umpire John Bacon (70) after being called for a clock violation during the first inning against the New York Mets at Citi Field. Mandatory Credit: Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images
MLB Umpire Faces Backlash After Questionable Calls in Yankees-Mets Game
MLB umpire John Bacon is under fire after controversial strike calls helped seal a Yankees win over the...
Read More
Jun 10, 2025; Henderson, NV, USA; Las Vegas Raiders defensive end Maxx Crosby (98) looks on during the team stretch during Las Vegas Raiders Minicamp at Intermountain Health Performance Center. Mandatory Credit: Candice Ward-Imagn Images
Patrick Mahomes Names Toughest NFL Pass-Rusher He's Faced
There’s no love lost between the Kansas City Chiefs and Las Vegas Raiders, but that doesn’t mean there’s...
Read More
Riders race into the first turn, on April 20, 2024, during the 73th annual men's Little 500 at Armstrong Stadium at Indiana University in Bloomington, IN.
Cyclist Refuses Podium After Losing to Transgender Winner
A female cyclist declined to appear on the podium after losing to a trans athlete, citing fairness in...
Read More

As an Amazon Associate, The Quick Report earns from qualifying purchases.

Part of the Castaway Studios media network.