Ranking the 15 Weirdest NFL Player Nicknames of All Time

Nicknames in the NFL are supposed to be intimidating, cool, or at the very least, make some sense. But occasionally, a nickname pops up, making you pause, scratch your head, and wonder what was happening in that locker room.

Whether it was a childhood moniker that stuck or a completely random label born from a bizarre moment, these weird nicknames have earned their place in football history. Here are the 15 weirdest NFL player nicknames, from fruits to fictional characters.

15. “The Law Firm” – BenJarvus Green-Ellis

BenJarvus Green-Ellis
Flickr

His nickname sounded more like a white-collar office on the 15th floor than a running back barreling through defenders. Still, “The Law Firm” stuck because his actual name felt like a legal team itself.

14. “Captain Munnerlyn” – Captain Munnerlyn

Captain Munnerlyn
Flickr

Yes, Captain is his real name, but it also worked as a nickname because it made him sound like a superhero or a guy running a pirate ship. Few players have ever been so accidentally on-brand.

13. “Whizzer” – Byron White

Byron White
Wikipedia

“Whizzer” is a wizard specializing in speed or a bathroom emergency. Either way, it’s an unforgettable nickname from a player who became a Supreme Court Justice.

12. “Touchdown Tony” – Tony Dorsett

Tony Dorsett
Wikimedia Commons

“Touchdown Tony” feels like something out of a cartoon more than an NFL playbook. It’s cheesy, a little corny, and precisely the kind of nickname you give a kid in youth football who’s way too good.

11. “The Nigerian Nightmare” – Christian Okoye

Christian Okoye
Wikipedia

This one was half terrifying, half WWE entrance. Christian Okoye earned it with his bruising style, but the nickname sounded like something you’d see on late-night cable TV in the ’90s.

10. “The Mad Stork” – Ted Hendricks

Ted Hendricks
Wikipedia

He was tall, lanky, and had all limbs—so naturally, someone looked at him and thought, “stork.” Throw in the “mad” part and you’ve got a player who sounds more like a children’s book villain than a Hall of Famer.

9. “Zeke Who?” – Ezekiel Elliott

Ezekiel Elliott
Wikimedia Commons

Okay, this one started as trash talk but somehow became a weird pseudo-nickname. It was like Cowboys fans adopted an insult and just ran with it.

8. “Orange Crush” – the Denver Broncos Defense

Denver Broncos linebacker Randy Gradishar
Wikipedia

Not a player, but worth mentioning because no defense should sound like a soft drink. The nickname was so strange and sugary that it somehow became iconic.

7. “Cadillac” – Carnell Williams

Carnell Williams
Wikipedia

When your nickname is a luxury car brand, expectations are immediately sky-high. Fortunately, Cadillac had a solid rookie year before his engine started misfiring.

6. “The Human Joystick” – Dante Hall

Dante Hall
Wikipedia

This made you picture a person surrounded by an invisible hand. It was weirdly accurate because nobody had moves like Dante Hall.

5. “The Amish Rifle” – Ryan Fitzpatrick

Ryan Fitzpatrick
Wikimedia Commons

Fitzpatrick had the beard, sure—but Amish? Not so much. Still, the nickname stuck and felt like a joke you tell your fantasy football league, not something you’d put on TV graphics.

4. “Beast Mode” – Marshawn Lynch

Marshawn Lynch
Flickr

At this point, “Beast Mode” feels normal because it has become part of the culture. But let’s be real—it’s not a nickname so much as a monster movie title.

3. “The Refrigerator” – William Perry

William Perry
Wikipedia

There’s nothing more football than naming a 300-pound lineman after a household appliance. “The Fridge” was weird, perfect, and completely unforgettable.

Read More: Ranking the 15 Weirdest Golfer Nicknames of All Time

2. “Deacon” – Deacon Jones

Deacon Jones
Flickr

He wasn’t a preacher, and his real name was David. But someone decided he needed an old-timey church title, and Deacon Jones was born—a nickname with zero logic and maximum staying power.

Read More: Ranking the 15 Funniest MLB Nicknames of All Time

1. “Bubby” – Bubby Brister

Bubby Brister
YouTube-The Sports Show

It’s the kind of name you’d give a toddler who can’t pronounce “buddy,” not a grown NFL quarterback. No one knows why it stuck, but Bubby remains one of the strangest nicknames in football history.

Read More: Ranking the 15 Funniest NFL Quarterback Nicknames of All Time

Related Articles
Mar 30, 1995; Chicago, IL, USA; Chicago Bulls guard Michael Jordan (45) talks with forward Scottie Pippen (33) after a timeout from the game against the Boston Celtics at Chicago Stadium. The Bulls beat the Celtics 100-82. Mandatory Credit: Matthew Emmons-Imagn Images
The 30 Coolest NBA Duos of All Time
These NBA pairs brought energy, swagger, and star power every time they shared the floor.
Read More
Oct 28, 2024; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; New York Giants quarterback Daniel Jones (8) runs the ball against the Pittsburgh Steelers during the fourth quarter at Acrisure Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images
The 15 Most Awkward Runners in NFL History
Whether it was stiff limbs or a complete lack of coordination, these 15 players made you do a double-take...
Read More
Payne Stewart
12 Golf Greats Who’d Be Totally Exposed on Modern Courses
Whether it’s the equipment, the competition, or the course design, these golf greats would have a rough...
Read More
Oct 29, 2000; Tampa, FL, USA; FILE PHOTO; Minnesota Vikings receiver (80) Cris Carter in action against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers at Raymond James Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Photo by Paul Chapman-USA TODAY Sports
20 NFL Players Who Changed Teams and Instantly Leveled Up
From forgotten backups to franchise cornerstones, these 20 players proved that sometimes all it takes...
Read More
Boston Red Sox designated hitter David Ortiz (34) tosses the pine tar rag before hitting in the fourth inning against the Cleveland Indians during game three of the 2016 ALDS playoff baseball series at Fenway Park.
14 MLB Players With Animalistic Strength
From legendary home run kings to modern-day powerhouses, this list celebrates 14 MLB players whose strength...
Read More
Apr 9, 2018; San Antonio, TX, USA; San Antonio Spurs shooting guard Manu Ginobili (20) reacts after a shot against the Sacramento Kings during the second half at AT&T Center. Mandatory Credit: Soobum Im-Imagn Images
16 NBA Stars Who Were Better as Sidekicks
Whether it was playing next to a dominant big man or an all-time great, here are 16 NBA stars who proved...
Read More

As an Amazon Associate, The Quick Report earns from qualifying purchases.

Part of the Castaway Studios media network.