Every NFL fanbase wants success, but some teams have all the resources, talent, and potential — and still find ways to underdeliver. Whether it’s constant rebuilds, coaching drama, or just good old-fashioned bad luck, these franchises leave fans wondering, “Why aren’t we better than this?”
These aren’t bottom-of-the-barrel teams with no hope — they’re the ones that should be doing more. From historic franchises to teams loaded with talent, here are 10 NFL squads that need to stop underachieving and start living up to the hype.
10. Minnesota Vikings
The Vikings always feel close, but never quite break through. With solid rosters year after year, fans are tired of “almost.”
9. Arizona Cardinals
They’ve had stars like Larry Fitzgerald and DeAndre Hopkins, yet can’t seem to build consistent success. The pieces are often there, but the results never are.
8. Las Vegas Raiders
The Raiders have the history, the fanbase, and now a shiny new home — but the wins? Not so much. For a franchise with this much swagger, mediocrity feels extra painful.
7. Atlanta Falcons
The Falcons had a 28-3 lead in the Super Bowl and still haven’t recovered. With offensive weapons galore over the years, fans have every right to want more.
6. New York Jets
Yes, expectations have been low for a while — but they shouldn’t be. With their New York market and recent roster investments, fans are tired of watching promise turn into disappointment.
5. Chicago Bears
This is one of the NFL’s oldest and most iconic franchises, but where’s the winning? Bears fans have endured way too many rebuilds and quarterback experiments for a team with this kind of legacy.
4. Cleveland Browns
The Browns were supposed to have turned the corner by now. With loaded rosters and years of high draft picks, the bar has officially been raised — and they keep limboing under it.
3. Dallas Cowboys
The Cowboys are always in the spotlight, always in the headlines, and always… not quite good enough. With the talent and brand they have, “just making the playoffs” isn’t cutting it.
Read More: 10 Reasons the Dallas Cowboys Are Still America’s Team
2. Los Angeles Chargers
The Chargers are basically allergic to reaching their full potential. With elite players and big-time buzz every offseason, fans are right to expect more than heartbreaking losses and missed opportunities.
Read More: Ranking the Top 20 Best NFL Mascots
1. Buffalo Bills
Buffalo has the talent, the quarterback, and a loyal fanbase desperate for a title. But after a few deep playoff runs with no Super Bowl appearance, it’s officially fair to demand more.
Read More: Ranking the 10 Most Emotionally Draining NFL Teams to Support
