10 NFL Quarterbacks Who Went in Round 1 – But Shouldn’t Have

The NFL Draft is about hope, hype, and occasional horrible decisions. For every superstar quarterback taken in the first round, there’s a handful that made teams question everything about their scouting department.

Sometimes, it’s a reach, sometimes desperation, and sometimes just plain bad luck. Whatever the reason, these ten QBs went in Round 1 and left fans wondering… why?

10. Christian Ponder

Christian Ponder
Youtube | Chicago Tribune

Drafting a quarterback just because you need one never really works out, and Ponder is proof. From the jump, he looked more like a placeholder than a franchise leader.

9. Paxton Lynch

Paxton Lynch
Youtube | Yohanis Shay

He had the size and the arm but absolutely none of the results. Denver was hoping for a new era — instead, they got a very short chapter.

8. Brandon Weeden

Brandon Weeden
Youtube | OfficialJaguar9

When your rookie quarterback is older than half the roster, something’s off. Cleveland tried to get cute and got burned instead.

7. Josh Rosen

Josh Rosen
Eric Chan/Wikimedia

He said there were nine mistakes ahead of him, but his own career was mistake No. 10. He was talented, sure, but the NFL never bought in, and neither did his teammates.

6. Jake Locker

Jake Locker
Wikimedia Commons

Locker had all the physical tools, but accuracy isn’t optional at the next level. Tennessee bet big on potential and lost big on Sundays.

5. Dwayne Haskins

Dwayne Haskins
Wikimedia Commons

A college star who never quite adjusted to the NFL speed. Washington jumped the gun on a guy who needed more time — and maybe a better situation.

4. Mitch Trubisky

Mitch Trubisky,Mitchell Trubisky
Wikipedia | Camrongood

Taken ahead of two future MVPs, Trubisky’s name is now synonymous with draft regret. Chicago wanted a hero but got a game manager with commitment issues.

3. Tim Tebow

Tim Tebow
Wikipedia | Jeffrey Beall

A first-round pick based on vibes and college highlight reels. He had the heart, no doubt — but throwing a football is kind of important too.

Read More: The Most Unexpected Draft Picks Who Became NFL Superstars

2. Johnny Manziel

Johnny Manziel
Youtube | RSHighlights

Johnny Football brought all the headlines but none of the consistency. Cleveland took a gamble on charisma and lost to reality.

Read More: 15 NFL Players Who Burned Bridges With Their Former Teams

1. JaMarcus Russell

JaMarcus Russell
Youtube | Harris Highlights

The ultimate cautionary tale. He had all the tools but forgot to read the manual — or any game film, apparently.

Read More: Every NFL Team’s Biggest QB Draft Bust, Ranked from Bad to Brutal

Related Articles
Damian Lillard
Bucks’ Redemption: Can Milwaukee Bounce Back on Home Turf?
The Milwaukee Bucks face a do-or-die challenge when they come home to Fiserv Forum for Game 3 of their...
Read More
Luka Doncic
Luka Magic: Can He Disrupt the Timberwolves’ Offensive Rhythm Against the Lakers?
As the 2025 NBA Playoffs heat up, the first-round battle between the Los Angeles Lakers and Minnesota...
Read More
Football on the 50 yard line
Steals in the Making? 5 Top NFL Prospects Still Waiting to Be Drafted on Day 2
The early part of the 2025 NFL Draft already had some heavy hitters flying off the board, but there are...
Read More

As an Amazon Associate, The Quick Report earns from qualifying purchases.

Part of the Castaway Studios media network.