Sometimes, a quarterback has all the tools but lands in the absolute worst situation. Whether it’s coaching chaos, no weapons, or a team in full-on rebuild mode, timing is everything in the NFL.
These quarterbacks might’ve had very different careers if they had landed elsewhere or showed up a few years earlier—or later. Instead, they were thrown into tough spots and left trying to make something work when the odds were stacked against them.
10. Blake Bortles – Jacksonville Jaguars
Bortles had talent and flashes of solid play, but Jacksonville wasn’t exactly a quarterback-friendly environment. It was like putting a spark plug in a lawn mower and expecting a Ferrari.
9. Josh Rosen – Arizona Cardinals
Rosen showed up just in time for the Cardinals to hit the reset button. One year, a new coach and a new quarterback later, he was out the door.
8. Sam Darnold – New York Jets
Darnold had potential, but the Jets gave him little to work with and way too much dysfunction. It was a classic case of wrong place, wrong system, wrong era.
7. Marcus Mariota – Tennessee Titans
Mariota needed a more creative offense and a little stability. Instead, he got multiple coordinators and a system that never really fit his strengths.
6. Justin Fields – Chicago Bears
Fields is athletic and exciting, but Chicago dropped him into a mess with a shaky line and a revolving door of play-callers. He was fighting for his life every snap, not building a career.
5. David Carr – Houston Texans
Carr was thrown to the wolves behind one of the worst offensive lines ever. By the time the Texans tried to fix things, it was already too late.
4. Zach Wilson – New York Jets
The Jets were rebuilding—again—and threw Wilson in as the savior way too early. Confidence matters and New York zapped his fast.
3. Alex Smith – San Francisco 49ers
Smith had about six different offensive coordinators in his first six years. He never had a chance to settle in before people were ready to move on.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Worst NFL Coaching Hires of All Time
2. Trevor Lawrence – Jacksonville Jaguars
Yes, he’s finding his way now, but Lawrence’s rookie year was a disaster, thanks to everything going on around him. Urban Meyer, enough said.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Overrated NFL Wide Receivers Playing Now
1. Mitchell Trubisky – Chicago Bears
Trubisky needed time, support, and smart development. Instead, he got unrealistic expectations and a city that was ready to turn on him by halftime.
Read More: Ranking the 11 Worst Quarterback Extensions of the Last 20 Years
