Some quarterbacks play the game. Others seem like they’re scripting a documentary about themselves while they play it. For these guys, the legacy wasn’t just a byproduct—it was practically the whole point.
Whether it was dramatic retirements or acting like they were the main character of the NFL at all times, these quarterbacks took themselves a little too seriously. Here are 15 QBs who got way too into their legacy.
15. Carson Wentz
At one point, he seemed destined to be the future of the league. Then he started acting like he’d already arrived, and the fall came fast and awkward.
14. Philip Rivers
He played with passion, fire, and a weird obsession with how he’d be remembered. That bolo tie had more swagger than his playoff resume.
13. Cam Newton
Cam was electric—and he knew it. The Superman celebrations were fun until it started feeling like he thought he was the hero of every game.
12. Joe Namath
The fur coats, the swagger, the one big win—Broadway Joe leaned into the persona like it was a full-time job. Decades later, the myth sometimes outpaces the reality.
11. Aaron Rodgers
The ayahuasca-fueled journey of legacy-building has been a sight to behold. It’s less about football now and more about “the experience” of being Aaron Rodgers.
10. Drew Brees
He was great, but somewhere along the way, he started chasing every last record like it was his personal Hall of Fame checklist. His retirement tour practically needed a second retirement tour.
9. Brett Favre
Favre’s career was incredible, but the endless retire-unretire cycle was legacy theater at its peak. He couldn’t let go—and needed everyone to feel how hard it was.
8. Jameis Winston
Despite the rollercoaster stat lines, he’s always talked like a guy writing the script to his own “30 for 30.” You admire the confidence even when the numbers don’t back it up.
7. Jimmy Garoppolo
You’d think he’d won three MVPs the way he carried himself sometimes. Being handsome and wearing a 49ers jersey doesn’t automatically make you Joe Montana.
6. Tim Tebow
Tebowmania was less about actual quarterback play and more about the mythology of Tim himself. He treated every snap like it was part of a much bigger story arc.
5. Russell Wilson
Let’s ride straight into the legacy obsession. Russ spent so much time managing his brand that it started to overshadow his actual performance.
4. Johnny Manziel
Johnny Football wasn’t just a nickname—it was an identity he clung to long after the success stopped. He wanted to be remembered as a legend, even if he barely made it out of his rookie contract.
3. Tom Brady
Greatest of all time? Sure. But the TB12 brand, the docuseries, the constant “proving people wrong” at 45—it’s legacy obsession turned lifestyle.
Read More:The Most Iconic Athlete from Each State
2. Peyton Manning
He wanted every audible detail, commercial, and even the slightest vein on the forehead to be part of the story. His post-career transition into a lovable pitchman just added another chapter to the Manning Mythos.
Read More: Ranking the 30 Best Quarterbacks of All Time
1. Colin Kaepernick
Kaepernick became bigger than football, and at some point, the legacy conversation began to detach from the actual games. Whether you admire it or roll your eyes, there’s no denying he curated how he’d be remembered every step of the way.
Read More: Legacy or One Last Shot? Aaron Rodgers Faces Final NFL Crossroads With Steelers as Only Option
