Some quarterbacks rise to the occasion. Others completely unravel when the lights are brightest and everything is on the line.
From playoff meltdowns to primetime flops, these QBs had their worst moments at the worst possible times. Whether it was nerves, pressure, or just plain overhype, these 15 signal-callers got exposed when it mattered most.
15. Andy Dalton
Dalton had plenty of solid regular seasons, but the moment the playoffs rolled around, it was panic mode. The Bengals made it to January, but their quarterback usually forgot how to play football once they got there.
14. Kirk Cousins
You like that? Vikings and Commanders fans sure didn’t when it came to crunch time. Cousins has put up good stats for years, but he’s made a habit of disappearing in the biggest moments.
13. Blake Bortles
For a hot second, it looked like Bortles was about to lead the Jaguars to a Super Bowl. Then reality came crashing down, and his limitations were brutally exposed under the spotlight.
12. Matt Schaub
Schaub had a nice run in Houston until the pressure got turned up and the pick-sixes started flying. When the stakes rose, his confidence—and the Texans’ playoff hopes—crumbled.
11. Mitchell Trubisky
The Bears kept trying to convince everyone he was the guy, but when it was time to deliver, Trubisky didn’t have the juice. The double-doink wasn’t his fault, but that entire game summed up his struggles under pressure.
10. Tony Romo
Romo was clutch until he wasn’t. He had his heroic moments, but he also had a knack for back-breaking picks and costly blunders in playoff games.
9. Carson Wentz
Wentz went from MVP candidate to liability real fast. Injuries played a role, but even when healthy, he looked lost in key games and couldn’t handle the heat.
8. Daunte Culpepper
Culpepper put up monster stats with Randy Moss, but things got shaky when the pressure was on. His postseason performances never quite lived up to his regular-season numbers.
7. Jared Goff
The Rams made a Super Bowl with Goff, but that big game made it painfully clear he wasn’t ready for the moment. It was like the Patriots downloaded his entire playbook—and his confidence.
6. Brock Osweiler
Osweiler fooled a lot of people into thinking he was a franchise guy. But under real scrutiny—and after a big payday—he completely collapsed when teams forced him to be the guy.
5. Chad Pennington
Smart, efficient, and respected… until the playoffs showed up. Pennington lacked the arm strength to truly elevate his teams when it counted most.
4. Jay Cutler
Cutler had the tools, but something always seemed off when it was go-time. Between questionable decisions and body language that screamed “I’m over this,” he flamed out when his team needed him most.
3. Mark Sanchez
Sanchez went to back-to-back AFC Championship Games, but let’s be honest—it wasn’t because of him. Once teams put the pressure on him to perform, the butt-fumble era began.
Read More: The Most Iconic Athlete from Each State
2. Jimmy Garoppolo
Jimmy G had elite defenses behind him and still found ways to underwhelm. Whether it was missing wide-open throws in the Super Bowl or just crumbling in crunch time, he never fully rose to the occasion.
Read More: Ranking the 30 Best Quarterbacks of All Time
1. Tony Eason
In one of the worst big-game performances ever, Eason didn’t even complete a pass in Super Bowl XX. When everything was on the line, he folded like a lawn chair in hurricane winds.
Read More: 15 Most Respectful Rivals in Sports History
