In the world of professional golf, where the accolades and achievements of players often translate into substantial earnings, there exists a fascinating contradiction: some of the sport’s most recognizable names have amassed fortunes that seem disproportionate to their on-course success.
These are the intriguing cases of golfers whose financial windfalls, influenced by factors beyond tournament victories, make them the most overpaid in the PGA and LIV circuits.
15. John Daly
John Daly’s career earnings of $10,270,681 from PGA Tour events belie his current estimated net worth of $2 million. Despite winning major tournaments, Daly’s financial struggles stem from gambling losses exceeding $50 million and multiple divorces. His colorful persona and long-hitting style made him popular, but his off-course issues significantly impacted his wealth.
14. Davis Love III
Despite a successful career with 21 PGA Tour wins, Davis Love III’s earnings seem disproportionate to his achievements. With career earnings of $44,959,243, he ranks 25th all-time, surpassing many players with more wins and major titles. His longevity and consistency contributed to this high total, rather than dominant performances.
13. Vijay Singh
Despite his impressive career, Vijay Singh’s earnings have raised eyebrows. With $71,236,216 in career earnings, Singh’s performance declined significantly after 2008. In 2020, he earned just $20,088 in 8 tournaments, yet his lifetime exemption keeps him on the tour. This disparity between recent performance and historical earnings places him among golf’s most overpaid players.
12. Ernie Els
Ernie Els, nicknamed “The Big Easy,” has earned nearly $50 million in PGA Tour winnings despite not winning a major since 2012. While his career includes four major championships, his earnings seem disproportionate to his recent performance. Els continues to earn substantial amounts from endorsements and business ventures, adding to his already impressive career earnings.
11. Bubba Watson
Bubba Watson has amassed career earnings of $62,739,812, including $48,049,778 from the PGA Tour and $7,365,875 from LIV Golf. Despite his impressive earnings, Watson’s inconsistent performance and controversial move to LIV Golf have led some to question whether his payouts match his on-course achievements.
10. Sergio Garcia
Despite his talent, Garcia’s earnings have raised eyebrows. With career earnings of $86,328,659 from PGA and LIV Golf combined, including $29,471,761 from LIV Golf alone, some argue his payouts outweigh his achievements. His highest-earning year was 2013-14, netting $4,939,606 from the PGA Tour.
9. Rickie Fowler
Despite his popularity, Rickie Fowler’s earnings have outpaced his performance. In 2025, he’s earned over $65 million in career earnings, including $56.3 million from PGA events, despite only six PGA Tour wins. His endorsements and marketability have contributed significantly to his wealth, often overshadowing his on-course results.
8. Jordan Spieth
Despite his early career success, Jordan Spieth’s recent performances have raised questions about his earnings. In 2025, Spieth’s career earnings reached $87.76 million, including $14.4 million from majors. However, his 2024-25 season started poorly, earning just $34,500 from one event, suggesting a potential decline in value relative to his pay.
7. Justin Rose
Despite his talent, Justin Rose’s earnings seem disproportionate to his performance. With career earnings of $71,624,786, Rose has only one major championship win. His inconsistent play, including multiple missed cuts in recent years, raises questions about his value compared to his substantial earnings.
6. Adam Scott
Despite his talent, Adam Scott’s earnings have outpaced his performance. With career earnings of $80.57 million as of 2025, Scott ranks among the top earners in PGA history. However, his single major win (2013 Masters) and 14 PGA Tour victories suggest a disparity between his paycheck and on-course achievements.
5. Jim Furyk
Jim Furyk has earned over $71 million in career PGA Tour earnings, ranking him 6th all-time. While a consistent performer, his single major win (2003 U.S. Open) and 17 total PGA Tour victories suggest he may be overcompensated compared to his achievements. Furyk’s unique swing and steady play have made him a fan favorite, but his earnings outpace his trophy cabinet.
4. Dustin Johnson
Despite his impressive career earnings of $75,557,026 on the PGA Tour, Dustin Johnson’s move to LIV Golf in 2022 raised eyebrows. He earned a staggering $35.6 million in his first season with LIV, including an $18 million bonus for winning the individual championship, far surpassing his PGA earnings.
Read More: 15 Mistakes Casual Golfers Make That Expose Them as Amateurs
3. Rory McIlroy
Despite his undeniable talent, Rory McIlroy’s earnings have raised eyebrows. In 2025, his net worth reached $170 million, with $45 million from endorsements alone. His career earnings topped $176 million, including $30.5 million from the Player Impact Program. While a gifted golfer, some argue his compensation outweighs his recent performances.
Read More: These 15 Golfers Are Dominating the Greens Right Now
2. Phil Mickelson
Despite his impressive career, Mickelson’s earnings have raised eyebrows. As of February 2025, he’s amassed $112.8 million in total career earnings, with $81 million from PGA Tour events. His controversial move to LIV Golf in 2022 netted him an additional $7 million, sparking debate about his value versus performance in recent years.
Read More: The 30 Greatest Golfers in the History of the Sport
1. Tiger Woods
Despite his legendary status, Tiger Woods tops the list of overpaid golfers. In 2025, his earnings reached $67 million, with only $12.2 million from on-course winnings. The bulk comes from endorsements and appearance fees, raising questions about value for performance in recent years.