While many cities boast about their thriving sports culture and claim to be among the top sports cities in America, the reality can often be starkly different from the perception.
This listicle examines 15 U.S. cities whose sports scenes might not be all they’re cracked up to be. From passionate fanbases left wanting by their teams’ performances to cities struggling with attendance issues, these entries reveal the underrated and overrated aspects of their sports environments.
15. Detroit
While they’ve had recent success (especially in football), Detroit’s sports scene remains overrated. The Lions’ playoff run was an anomaly, and the Tigers’ 2024 surge seems unsustainable. With inconsistent performances across other major leagues and low attendance figures, Detroit’s claim as a top sports city is questionable. The city ranked just 24th in MLB attendance in 2024, highlighting fan engagement issues.
14. Phoenix
Despite hosting major teams like the Suns, Cardinals, and Diamondbacks, Phoenix’s sports scene lacks the passionate fan culture found in other cities. The extreme heat often keeps fans away, resulting in lackluster attendance. While the city has hosted major events like the Super Bowl, its overall sports atmosphere falls short of expectations for a market its size.
13. Seattle
Sorry to the fans, but Seattle’s sports scene falls short. The Seahawks’ recent decline, the Mariners’ playoff drought, and the Kraken’s underwhelming start have dampened enthusiasm. The loss of the SuperSonics still stings, and the city’s rainy weather often hampers outdoor events. Seattle’s sports culture, while dedicated, hasn’t translated into consistent success across major leagues.
12. Denver
While Denver boasts passionate fans, its sports scene is often overhyped. The Broncos’ recent struggles have dampened enthusiasm, and the Nuggets’ 2023 NBA championship hasn’t fully elevated the city’s status. The Rockies consistently underperform, and the Avalanche’s success is overshadowed by larger hockey markets. Denver’s thin air advantage is often exaggerated, making it a solid but overrated sports city.
11. Houston
Despite recent success in baseball and basketball, Houston’s sports scene lacks the passionate fan base and iconic venues of truly great sports cities. The Texans struggle to fill NRG Stadium, and the Rockets’ attendance has dwindled. While the Astros remain popular, their tainted 2017 World Series win still casts a shadow over the city’s sports legacy.
10. Atlanta
Atlanta hosts major events like the 2025 College Football Playoff National Championship and 2025 MLB All-Star Game, but their sports scene often falls short of expectations. The city’s teams, including the Falcons, Braves, and Hawks, have a history of playoff disappointments and inconsistent performances, leaving fans frustrated and questioning Atlanta’s status as a top sports city.
9. Washington, D.C.
While they boast teams in all major leagues, D.C.’s sports scene is mediocre. The Commanders have certainly come to life over the last year, but the Nationals and Wizards have seen better days. Even the Capitals’ recent success hasn’t elevated the city’s overall sports culture. D.C.’s transient population contributes to inconsistent fan support across its teams.
8. San Francisco
Let’s face it, San Francisco’s sports scene is kind of average at the moment. The 49ers’ success is overshadowed by the Warriors’ recent struggles and the Giants’ inconsistency. The city’s high cost of living makes attending games prohibitively expensive for many fans, diminishing the overall sports atmosphere.
7. Dallas
While they certainly have a passionate fanbase, Dallas struggles to live up to its “sports city” hype. The Cowboys haven’t won a Super Bowl since 1995, while the Mavericks and Stars have each claimed only one championship. The Rangers’ lone World Series appearance ended in defeat. Dallas’ sports scene often promises more than it delivers.
6. Philadelphia
Philadelphia sports fans are passionate, but they’ve been left disappointed in recent years. The Eagles’ recent Super Bowl appearance masks years of mediocrity across other teams. The 76ers struggle to advance in playoffs, the Flyers haven’t won a Stanley Cup since 1975, and the Phillies’ 2022 World Series run was an anomaly. The city’s sports culture often overshadows actual achievements.
5. Miami
While Miami boasts championship-winning teams like the Heat and Marlins, its sports culture often lacks consistency. Fair-weather fans and frequently empty stadiums plague the city, despite hosting major events like the Super Bowl. The Dolphins’ long playoff drought and the Marlins’ low attendance further diminish Miami’s sports reputation.
Read More: The Ultimate Super Bowl Guide for Non-Football Fans
4. Chicago
Chicago’s sports scene has been underwhelming in recent years. The Bears, Bulls, and Blackhawks struggle to recapture past glories, while the Cubs and White Sox face inconsistency. The city’s teams combined for a dismal 37.5% winning percentage in 2024, marking the worst year in Chicago sports history.
Read More: The 20 Most Cursed Fanbases in Professional Sports
3. Boston
While Boston has had lots of success and just won the NBA Championship, for some reason they’re also overhyped. The Patriots are struggling post-Brady, and the Red Sox face fierce AL East competition.
Read More: 20 NFL Fan Traditions That Will Leave You in Stitches
2. Los Angeles
Despite its star-studded teams and recent successes, Los Angeles struggles with fan loyalty and attendance issues. The Chargers and Rams face challenges filling their state-of-the-art SoFi Stadium, while the Dodgers and Lakers often see fans arrive late and leave early. The city’s traffic and diverse entertainment options contribute to its lukewarm sports culture.
Read More: 20 NBA Trades That Left Fans Stunned and Speechless
1. New York City
For a city as beloved as New York City, they really haven’t seen championship success in a long time. High ticket prices, crowded venues, and inconsistent team performances detract from the experience. While the city boasts passionate fans, the overall atmosphere can be overwhelming for casual spectators, making it less enjoyable than smaller markets with more intimate settings.
Watch Now: Big plays. Fast takes. Check out TQR Shorts for the latest sports news with Zoe!