20 NHL Stars Who Played Like the Team Was Just a Supporting Cast

Some players see their team as a unit. Others see it as background noise to the main act—starring them, directed by them, with a rotating cast of extras just lucky to share the ice.

This list is dedicated to those NHL stars who operated like it was their show, and everyone else was just a footnote. From eye-popping skill to off-the-charts confidence, these guys made it pretty clear: the team existed to support them.

20. Evander Kane

Evander Kane
Wikimedia Commons

Whether it was in Atlanta, Winnipeg, Buffalo, or San Jose, Kane never lacked confidence in his game. Subtlety wasn’t really in his playbook, and neither was blending into a system.

19. Jeremy Roenick

Jeremy Roenick
Flickr

Roenick didn’t just play the game—he marketed himself like a walking highlight reel. He wanted goals, interviews, and all eyes on him, preferably all at once.

18. Rick Nash

Rick Nash
Wikimedia Commons

In his Columbus days, Nash was the Blue Jackets. If the puck wasn’t on his stick, you could bet he was wondering why not.

17. Sean Avery

Sean Avery
Flickr

Let’s be honest—Avery never seemed all that interested in “team-first” hockey. He was too busy being the villain, the showman, and the guy stirring the pot.

16. P.K. Subban

P.K. Subban
Flickr

Subban was electric on the ice and never shied away from attention off it. He brought flair to the rink—and let’s just say he didn’t exactly hide in the shadows.

15. Patrick Roy

Patrick Roy
Flickr

Goalies usually aren’t the showboating type, but Roy was never content with just stopping pucks. He made it clear he was the main character, even if the rest of the team was just trying to keep up.

14. Dany Heatley

Dany Heatley
Wikimedia Commons

You don’t call yourself “All-Star” in the third person unless you truly believe you’re the center of the hockey universe. Heatley played like every shift was his time to shine—and the rest of the guys were lucky to be there.

13. Eric Lindros

Eric Lindros
Flickr

Lindros didn’t just play for Philly—he was Philly, at least in his mind. It worked for a while, until the tension with management showed that he wasn’t exactly a “team guy.”

12. Tony DeAngelo

Tony DeAngelo
Flickr

When you’re known as much for your opinions as your play, it’s clear you’re writing your own script. DeAngelo’s puck-carrying style (and everything else) screamed “I’ve got this.”

11. Alex Kovalev

Alex Kovalev
Flickr

Kovalev’s skill was ridiculous, and he knew it. Some nights it looked like he was playing a different game—and waiting for his teammates to catch up.

10. Ilya Kovalchuk

Ilya Kovalchuk
Wikimedia Commons

Give Kovalchuk the puck and get out of the way—that was the vibe. He wasn’t really out there for the team game, just goals and glory.

9. Brad Marchand

Brad Marchand
Flickr

Sure, Marchand can play a system. But let’s be real—he’d rather stir chaos, score goals, and be the center of attention while doing both.

8. Brett Hull

Brett Hull
Flickr

Hull didn’t love practice, but he loved scoring goals. And when you’re filling the net like he did, why wouldn’t you act like the team’s just there to feed you pucks?

7. Sergei Fedorov

Sergei Fedorov
Flickr

Fedorov could do everything—and sometimes looked like he’d rather do it all himself. He wasn’t always in sync with the team, but he was undeniably elite.

6. Pavel Bure

Pavel Bure
Wikimedia Commons

Bure’s game was speed, flair, and all-out offense. He didn’t just play on the team—he played above it.

5. Patrick Kane

Patrick Kane
Wikimedia Commons

Kane often looked like he was controlling the game with a joystick, not a stick. His puck skills were outrageous—and it often felt like the Blackhawks were just lucky to be included.

4. Alexei Yashin

Alexei Yashin
Wikimedia Commons

Yashin played like a superstar and expected to be treated like royalty. He didn’t always deliver team-first results, but he always made it about him.

3. Auston Matthews

Auston Matthews
Wikimedia Commons

Matthews plays with that quiet swagger that says, “This is my stage.” He can back it up—but you still get the sense that he’s the headliner, no matter who’s around him.

Read More: Boo-Worthy but Brilliant: Ranking the 7 NHL Players Fans Loved to Hate

2. Alex Ovechkin

Alex Ovechkin
Flickr

Ovechkin is a force of nature who’s been chasing goals (and celebrations) like no one else. Yes, he’s a great teammate—but let’s not pretend this isn’t the Ovi Show.

Read More: 15 Controversial Changes To Sports Rules That Outraged Fans

1. Connor McDavid

Connor McDavid
Flickr

McDavid is so freakishly good that the team often has to revolve around him. It’s not ego—it’s just reality when one player is this far ahead of the rest of the league.

Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Arrogant NHL Players of All Time

Related Articles
Oct 4, 2017; Minneapolis, MN, USA; Minnesota Lynx forward Maya Moore (23) dribbles in the first quarter against the Los Angeles Sparks guard Odyssey Sims (1) in Game 5 of the WNBA Finals at Williams Arena. Mandatory Credit: Brad Rempel-Imagn Images
14 WNBA Athletes Who Redefined Strength and Skill
These athletes didn’t just play the game; they changed the way we think about what women can do on the...
Read More
Nov 23, 2024; Morgantown, West Virginia, USA; UCF Knights head coach Gus Malzahn yells at quarterback Dylan Rizk (10) during the first quarter against the West Virginia Mountaineers at Mountaineer Field at Milan Puskar Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Ben Queen-Imagn Images
14 College Football Coaches Who Thought They Were Smarter Than Everyone Else
From overcomplicating game plans to condescending press conferences, these coaches walked around like...
Read More
May 10, 2025; East Rutherford, NJ, USA; New York Giants head coach Brian Daboll looks on during rookie minicamp at Quest Diagnostics Training Center. Mandatory Credit: John Jones-Imagn Images
12 NFL Coaches Who Thought They Were the Main Character
Whether it was the press conferences or the “my way or the highway” mentality, these guys weren’t just...
Read More

As an Amazon Associate, The Quick Report earns from qualifying purchases.

Part of the Castaway Studios media network.