Some quarterbacks rack up stats, others rack up wins, and a select few somehow rack up unwarranted praise. Whether it was a fluke season, a strong supporting cast, or a good PR team, these guys were talked about like legends when they were just fine.
This list isn’t about pure busts or obvious backups. These are the quarterbacks who were treated like franchise saviors, face-of-the-league types—only for reality to eventually catch up and say, “Wait a second, were they even that good?”
15. Matt Cassel
One hot year in New England had people thinking he was the next great Belichick creation. Then he left, and the magic instantly vanished.
14. Blake Bortles
He had one solid playoff run and a ton of garbage-time stats. Somehow, that was enough for a brief moment of “Is Bortles elite?” energy.
13. Jay Cutler
A rocket arm and resting smug face masked years of mediocrity. People kept waiting for him to turn the corner—he never did.
12. Daunte Culpepper
Randy Moss made him look a lot better than he was. Once Moss was gone, so was the illusion of greatness.
11. Carson Wentz
One MVP-caliber season got everyone hooked. Then came the injuries, the turnovers, and the reality check.
10. Matt Schaub
For a minute there, he was a Pro Bowl guy with gaudy stats. Then came the pick-sixes and a quick fade into irrelevance.
9. Kerry Collins
People loved talking about his arm strength and toughness. But outside of one Super Bowl run, it was mostly talk.
8. Jeff George
All the tools, none of the results. Coaches and fans kept convincing themselves it would eventually click—it never did.
7. Tony Banks
He always looked the part which fooled many people. However, the production never quite lived up to the hype.
6. Marc Bulger
He slid into “Great Show on Turf” mode and coasted off it for a while. Once things got harder, he faded fast.
5. Nick Foles
Yes, he won the Super Bowl MVP award. But outside that miracle run, his career was a rollercoaster of backup-worthy performances.
4. Brian Griese
He inherited John Elway’s job and got talked up like a future star. But he never delivered more than occasional flashes.
3. Chris Weinke
A Heisman winner who got NFL buzz purely off reputation. On the field? It never matched the résumé.
Read More: The 15 Most Ridiculous Athlete Fines of All Time
2. Mitchell Trubisky
Drafted ahead of Mahomes and Watson, which unfairly boosted expectations. The Bears tried to make him “the guy”—but the league quickly figured him out.
Read More: Michael Penix Jr. Seeks Guidance from Falcons Legend Matt Ryan as He Prepares for QB1 Role
1. Mark Sanchez
He went to two AFC Championship Games, and people thought he was destined for stardom. Turns out it was just a really good defense and a whole lot of pretending.
Read More: 14 Quarterbacks Who Were a PR Nightmare Waiting to Happen
