10 NFL Players We Assumed Were Done… Before They Made Epic Comebacks

The NFL is a brutal league—once a player struggles with injuries, age, or a rough stretch, people are quick to write them off. 

But some guys refuse to let their careers end quietly and come back stronger than ever. Here are 10 NFL players who everyone thought were done but made epic comebacks.

10. Alex Smith

Alex Smith
Openverse

After suffering a gruesome leg injury that led to 17 surgeries and nearly cost him his life, nobody expected Smith to ever play again. But in 2020, he not only returned to the field—he helped Washington make the playoffs, cementing one of the most inspiring comebacks in NFL history.

9. Michael Vick

Michael Vick
Wiki Commons

Vick’s career seemed completely over after his prison sentence for dogfighting, but he got a second chance with the Eagles. In 2010, he put together an MVP-caliber season, proving he still had that electrifying playmaking ability.

8. Peyton Manning

Peyton Manning
Openverse

After multiple neck surgeries and getting cut by the Colts, it looked like Manning’s career was finished. Then he joined the Broncos, threw 55 touchdowns in a season, won an MVP, and rode off into the sunset with a Super Bowl ring.

7. Adrian Peterson

Adrian Peterson
Openverse

Most running backs don’t come back from a torn ACL, but Peterson isn’t most running backs. A year after tearing his knee up, he nearly broke the single-season rushing record and won NFL MVP.

6. Rob Gronkowski

Rob Gronkowski
Wikimedia Commons

Gronk retired in 2019 due to injuries, and it seemed like his Hall of Fame career was over. Then he unretired, joined Brady in Tampa Bay, and won another Super Bowl like he never even left.

5. Doug Flutie

Doug Flutie
Wiki Commons

Flutie was completely written off by the NFL and spent years dominating the CFL before getting another shot. When he returned to the league in the late ‘90s, he became a Pro Bowler with the Bills and gave us one of the best underdog stories in football.

4. Eric Berry

Eric Berry
Flickr

Berry was one of the best safeties in the league before being diagnosed with Hodgkin’s lymphoma. After beating cancer, he came back and made the Pro Bowl, proving that nothing could stop him.

3. Brett Favre

Brett Favre
Wikipedia

Favre retired (then un-retired), struggled in New York, and then looked completely washed. Then he went to Minnesota, had an MVP-level season at 40 years old, and took the Vikings to the NFC Championship.

Read More: The 10 Most Inspirational Career-Defining Comebacks in NFL History

2. Garrison Hearst

Garrison Hearst
Youtube | ClassActSports

Hearst’s gruesome ankle injury was so bad that doctors weren’t sure he’d ever walk normally again. Two years later, he returned to the NFL, ran for over 1,200 yards, and made the Pro Bowl.

Read More: The 10 Shortest Quarterbacks Who Ever Made NFL History

1. Tom Brady

Tom Brady
Flickr

At 40 years old, people thought Brady was nearing the end—then he led the biggest Super Bowl comeback ever. Then, when the Patriots moved on, he went to Tampa Bay and won another Super Bowl, just for fun.

Read More: The 10 Most Inspirational Comeback Stories in NFL History

Related Articles
Damian Lillard
Bucks’ Redemption: Can Milwaukee Bounce Back on Home Turf?
The Milwaukee Bucks face a do-or-die challenge when they come home to Fiserv Forum for Game 3 of their...
Read More
Luka Doncic
Luka Magic: Can He Disrupt the Timberwolves’ Offensive Rhythm Against the Lakers?
As the 2025 NBA Playoffs heat up, the first-round battle between the Los Angeles Lakers and Minnesota...
Read More
Football on the 50 yard line
Steals in the Making? 5 Top NFL Prospects Still Waiting to Be Drafted on Day 2
The early part of the 2025 NFL Draft already had some heavy hitters flying off the board, but there are...
Read More

As an Amazon Associate, The Quick Report earns from qualifying purchases.

Part of the Castaway Studios media network.