The world of sports is filled with triumphs and challenges, with athletes often held to high standards both on and off the field. However, for some NFL players, their off-field controversies have overshadowed their on-field achievements.
We’re looking at 15 NFL players whose careers were marred by scandals and legal troubles, exploring the complexities of fame, responsibility, and the consequences of actions. Through these stories, we gain insight into the pitfalls that can accompany professional success and the importance of reputation in the public eye.
15. Aaron Hernandez
Aaron Hernandez’s promising NFL career with the New England Patriots was marred by his involvement in several high-profile crimes. He was convicted of murder and later acquitted of a double homicide before his death in prison. Hernandez was posthumously diagnosed with CTE.
14. Ray Rice
Ray Rice’s NFL career ended abruptly after a domestic violence incident in 2014. He was indefinitely suspended and later reinstated, but never signed with another team. Rice has since worked to rebuild his reputation through community service and domestic violence awareness efforts.
13. O.J. Simpson
O.J. Simpson, a legendary NFL running back, was the first to rush over 2,000 yards in a season. However, his reputation was marred by a highly publicized murder trial and acquittal in 1994. He passed away on April 10, 2024, at the age of 76.
12. Michael Vick
Michael Vick’s NFL career was marred by a dogfighting scandal in 2007, leading to a 23-month prison sentence. Despite this, he returned to the NFL with the Philadelphia Eagles in 2009 and became an advocate for animal rights. His journey highlights both downfall and redemption.
11. Adrian Peterson
Adrian Peterson’s reputation was severely damaged by a child abuse case in 2014, leading to a season-long suspension. Despite earning nearly $100 million in his NFL career, he has faced financial issues, including multiple lawsuits over defaulted loans.
10. Greg Hardy
Greg Hardy’s NFL career was marred by a domestic violence incident, leading to a 10-game suspension. He later pursued an MMA career but faced further controversy with a cocaine possession arrest. Hardy’s actions significantly damaged his reputation in the sports world.
9. Darren Sharper
Darren Sharper, a former NFL safety, was convicted of drugging and sexually assaulting women across four states. He pleaded guilty and was sentenced to 20 years in prison in 2016. Sharper’s career included stints with the Packers, Vikings, and Saints, but his legacy is marred by his crimes.
8. Rae Carruth
Rae Carruth, a former Carolina Panthers wide receiver, was convicted of conspiracy to commit murder after hiring a hitman to kill his pregnant girlfriend, Cherica Adams. He served over 18 years in prison and was released in 2018. His case remains one of the NFL’s most infamous scandals.
7. Plaxico Burress
Plaxico Burress, a Super Bowl XLII hero, saw his career marred by a gun incident in 2008. He accidentally shot himself in a nightclub, leading to a two-year prison sentence and suspension from the NFL. His reputation suffered due to legal issues and financial irresponsibility.
6. Lawrence Taylor
Lawrence Taylor, a legendary linebacker, won two Super Bowls with the New York Giants. However, his legacy is marred by off-field issues, including cocaine addiction and a conviction for criminal sexual conduct with a minor. Financial struggles and legal battles further complicated his post-football life.
5. Richie Incognito
Richie Incognito’s reputation was marred by the 2013 “Bullygate” scandal, where he was accused of bullying teammate Jonathan Martin. Recently, Martin stated he never felt bullied, leading Incognito to claim the media ruined his career with false narratives.
4. Antonio Brown
Antonio Brown’s NFL career was marred by controversies, including legal issues and erratic behavior. He filed for bankruptcy in 2023 despite earning over $80 million, and his recent social media posts have sparked outrage, further damaging his reputation.
3. Deshaun Watson
Deshaun Watson’s reputation has been marred by injuries and controversy. He recently suffered a second Achilles rupture, potentially missing the 2025 season, and has faced numerous sexual assault allegations, leading to suspensions and settlements. His performance has been underwhelming since signing a $230 million contract.
2. Henry Ruggs III
Henry Ruggs III’s NFL career was cut short after a fatal DUI crash in 2021. He was charged with multiple felonies and faces up to 50 years in prison if convicted. The Las Vegas Raiders immediately released him following the incident.
Read More: 10 Players Blacklisted from the NFL
1. Kareem Hunt
Kareem Hunt’s NFL career was marred by a 2018 hotel incident where he shoved and kicked a woman, leading to his release from the Chiefs and an eight-game suspension. Despite this, he continued playing for the Browns after serving his suspension.
Read More: 8 Convicted NFL Players Who Went from Hero to Villain