Every sport has its villains, but football also has its fair share of genuinely great guys—the kind of players who made you proud to cheer for their team regardless of who you rooted for. These are the NFL stars who played the game the right way, gave back off the field, and always seemed to carry themselves with class, humility, and heart.
Whether they were helping communities, mentoring younger teammates, or just flashing a constant smile despite the pressure, these guys won over fans everywhere. From all-time legends to underrated fan favorites, here are 15 NFL good guys everyone could root for.
15. Tony Gonzalez
A generational tight end with a heart of gold, Tony Gonzalez was as well-known for his off-field leadership as his on-field dominance. He always came across as gracious, humble, and determined to leave the game better than he found it.
14. Fred Warner
Fred Warner is a modern good guy with an old-school heart. He’s all about hard work, quiet leadership, and doing things the right way—exactly the kind of player fans love to cheer for.
13. Andrew Luck
Andrew Luck’s surprise retirement shocked the NFL, but it only made fans love him more. His goofy, polite personality (especially when he’d congratulate defenders for hitting him) was the stuff of legend.
12. Chris Long
Chris Long didn’t just make plays—he made a difference. The former defensive end donated his entire 2017 salary to educational initiatives and never stopped using his platform to do good.
11. Russell Wilson
Say what you want about his corniness—Russell Wilson’s commitment to giving back, especially to kids and hospitals, has always been admirable. His “Why Not You” attitude has inspired more than just Seahawks and Broncos fans.
10. Kurt Warner
Kurt Warner went from stocking shelves to Super Bowl MVP, and he never let fame change who he was. His faith, humility, and kindness made him a beloved figure both during and after his career.
9. Jason Kelce
Jason Kelce is the kind of guy who will shotgun a beer with fans and then quietly support countless charities behind the scenes. He’s been a blue-collar hero on and off the field for years.
8. Reggie White
Nicknamed “The Minister of Defense,” Reggie White was as gentle and inspiring off the field as he was dominant on it. He was deeply respected not just for his play but for his leadership and compassion.
7. Thomas Davis
Thomas Davis tore his ACL three times—and kept coming back stronger. But it’s his dedication to community work and mentoring that truly sets him apart as one of the NFL’s most admirable leaders.
6. Troy Polamalu
Troy Polamalu let his hair fly on Sundays, but off the field, he was quiet, humble, and deeply spiritual. He played with unmatched intensity but lived with a soft, generous spirit.
5. J.J. Watt
Few athletes have done more for their community than J.J. Watt, especially after Hurricane Harvey devastated Houston. His work ethic, charisma, and heart made him a fan favorite league-wide.
4. Barry Sanders
Barry Sanders ran like lightning but never made it about himself. He walked away from the game at his peak, always letting his play speak louder than his words.
3. Peyton Manning
Peyton Manning was more than just a football genius—he was hilarious, genuine, and widely respected by teammates and rivals alike. His charity work and down-to-earth nature only added to his legacy.
2. Walter Payton
“Sweetness” wasn’t just his nickname—it was how he treated people. Walter Payton’s grace, both as a player and a person, made him a beloved icon of the game.
Read More: 20 NFL Stars Who Proved Scouts Don’t Always Know Best
1. Larry Fitzgerald
You’d be hard-pressed to find anyone with a bad word to say about Larry Fitzgerald. A loyal, hardworking, and ultra-respectful receiver, he defined sportsmanship throughout his career in Arizona.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Wholesome NFL Friendships of All Time
