Quarterbacks are supposed to be the cool, confident faces of the franchise. But every now and then, we get a signal-caller who looks more comfortable breaking down coverages than making small talk in the locker room.
Some of these guys gave off major “don’t talk to me at lunch” energy, while others were just quirky enough to leave teammates scratching their heads. Whether it was robotic pressers, bizarre interviews, or just an all-around offbeat vibe, these QBs brought some lovable (and occasionally cringe-worthy) awkwardness to the huddle.
20. Josh Rosen
He had the talent, but his aloofness made it hard for teammates to fully connect. Rosen often came off like the smartest guy in the room—and wasn’t afraid to act like it.
19. Jay Cutler
Cutler always looked like he’d rather be anywhere else than answering a question. His vibe screamed “forced group project partner who does all the work but hates the experience.”
18. Sam Darnold
He gave off “shy kid at the party” energy pretty much his entire time in New York. Even when he tried to be assertive, it somehow came out quiet and confused.
17. Marcus Mariota
He’s polite to a fault and about as animated as a bowl of oatmeal. No one has ever made fewer waves as a starting quarterback.
16. Christian Hackenberg
From awkward rookie interviews to being visibly uncomfortable in the spotlight, Hackenberg looked perpetually out of sync. He might’ve thrived more in a study hall than a huddle.
15. Joey Harrington
He brought a piano to his rookie photo shoot and somehow still managed to look nervous. Harrington’s clean-cut, bookish demeanor never really fit the “alpha QB” mold.
14. Tim Tebow
His relentless positivity and ultra-wholesome vibe weirded out some teammates. Off the field, he often felt more like a motivational speaker than a locker room leader.
13. Brock Osweiler
Osweiler looked the part but never quite acted like he knew what to do with it. His postgame interviews were filled with polite pauses and odd phrasing that never quite landed.
12. Mitchell Trubisky
His entire tenure in Chicago felt like watching a guy who accidentally got picked to be the team captain and didn’t know how to say no. Even his celebration attempts felt forced and clunky.
11. Chris Weinke
A 28-year-old rookie with dad energy and a deer-in-the-headlights expression. His vibe was “youth pastor trying to coach high school football.”
10. Blaine Gabbert
Gabbert always looked like he was about to ask someone for the Wi-Fi password. He had the blank stare of a guy who wasn’t totally sure where he was half the time.
9. Zach Wilson
From awkward pressers to cringey TikTok rumors, Zach never quite mastered the art of social awareness. He seemed more comfortable with a playbook than with people.
8. Cade McNown
McNown had the confidence of a guy who had never heard of self-awareness. His interactions with teammates bordered on “Do you even like these people?”
7. Brady Quinn
His whole NFL stint felt like an extended job interview that he didn’t prepare for. He was polished to the point of being painfully stiff.
6. Jimmy Clausen
Clausen walked into the league with swagger but spoke like he was constantly trying to convince himself he belonged. His delivery was stilted and awkward, especially under pressure.
5. Ryan Leaf
He had plenty of bark, but his social skills were closer to “loud guy at the wrong party.” Every interview felt one outburst away from spiraling into chaos.
4. Ken Dorsey
Even as a coach, Dorsey’s facial expressions look like he’s calculating taxes in his head. As a player, he had the charisma of a confused substitute teacher.
3. Jason Campbell
Campbell was quiet, polite, and just kind of… there. He gave off the energy of someone who triple-checks their texts before sending them.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Overhyped NFL Teams of the Last 25 Years
2. Andrew Luck
One of the most likable awkward guys to ever play, Luck sounded like a Civil War reenactor who just discovered football. His laugh was part endearing, part confusing—and always memorable.
Read More: 17 NFL Quarterbacks Who Let Fame Get to Their Heads
1. Eli Manning
Eli was elite at two things: winning Super Bowls and making facial expressions that screamed “Wait, what’s happening?” His dry, emotionless delivery and blank stares made him a legend of accidental awkwardness.
Read More: These Are the 30 Most Likeable NFL Quarterbacks of All Time
