The NFL has been home to countless legends, but only a rare group has earned the unwavering respect of fans, peers, and rivals alike. These are the players whose influence went beyond stats—defined by their excellence, leadership, and integrity.
From dominating between the lines to shaping the sport’s culture and making a difference beyond the field, these 30 athletes stand as some of the most respected figures in NFL history.
30. Jason Witten (TE, 2003-2020)
A model of consistency and professionalism, Witten was the heart and soul of the Dallas Cowboys for nearly two decades. His work ethic and leadership made him one of the most beloved tight ends in NFL history.
29. Junior Seau (LB, 1990-2009)
One of the greatest linebackers of all time, Seau’s passion for the game and relentless energy made him a fan favorite. His tragic passing in 2012 only highlighted his importance to the sport and the impact he had on his peers.
28. Steve Largent (WR, 1976-1989)
Before Jerry Rice rewrote the record books, Largent was the gold standard at wide receiver. His precise route running and sure hands made him one of the most respected offensive players of his era.
27. Tony Dungy (DB/Coach, 1977-1979, Head Coach 1996-2008)
Dungy had a short playing career but became one of the most respected figures in the NFL as a coach and mentor. His leadership and emphasis on character over talent helped redefine what it meant to be a head coach.
26. Gale Sayers (RB, 1965-1971)
Although his career was cut short by injuries, Sayers’ electric running ability and sportsmanship made him one of the most respected and beloved players of his era.
25. Russell Wilson (QB, 2012-Present)
Despite recent struggles, Wilson’s early career success, leadership, and commitment to community service have made him a highly respected figure in the league.
24. Barry Sanders (RB, 1989-1998)
Sanders was one of the most electrifying players to ever play the game, but his humility and team-first mentality made him even more respected. His shocking early retirement only added to his legacy.
23. Ray Lewis (LB, 1996-2012)
A fiery leader and one of the greatest defensive players ever, Lewis’ passion and commitment to excellence made him a respected figure among players and coaches alike.
22. Fran Tarkenton (QB, 1961-1978)
A pioneer at the quarterback position, Tarkenton’s innovation and competitiveness made him one of the most admired signal-callers in NFL history.
21. Peyton Manning (QB, 1998-2015)
Few quarterbacks were as respected as Manning, both for his preparation and leadership. His impact on the game extends far beyond his playing days, as he continues to be a face of the NFL.
20. Reggie White (DE, 1984-2000)
“The Minister of Defense” was as dominant on the field as he was respected off of it. His leadership and character made him one of the most beloved figures in league history.
19. Walter Payton (RB, 1975-1987)
“Sweetness” was not just an incredible player but also one of the most respected human beings to ever play in the NFL. His legacy of kindness and excellence is honored through the Walter Payton Man of the Year Award.
18. Joe Greene (DT, 1969-1981)
“Mean” Joe Greene was the heart of the legendary Steelers defense in the 1970s, but his leadership and class made him an icon beyond the game.
17. Johnny Unitas (QB, 1956-1973)
One of the first superstar quarterbacks, Unitas’ toughness and professionalism helped shape the modern game.
16. Tom Brady (QB, 2000-2022)
Whether you love him or hate him, Brady’s commitment to excellence and ability to perform under pressure have made him one of the most respected players in NFL history.
15. Jim Brown (RB, 1957-1965)
Brown was the most dominant running back of his era and a powerful advocate for social justice, making him one of the most respected figures in football history.
14. Larry Fitzgerald (WR, 2004-2020)
A consummate professional, Fitzgerald was known for his class on and off the field, earning respect from teammates and rivals alike.
13. Charles Woodson (CB/S, 1998-2015)
One of the most versatile defensive backs in NFL history, Woodson’s leadership and longevity made him one of the most respected players of his time.
12. Brett Favre (QB, 1991-2010)
Favre’s love for the game and toughness made him a legend. His ability to play through pain and always give 100% earned him respect throughout the league.
11. Drew Brees (QB, 2001-2020)
Brees’ impact on and off the field, particularly in the New Orleans community post-Hurricane Katrina, made him one of the most beloved and respected figures in NFL history.
10. Deion Sanders (CB/WR, 1989-2005)
“Prime Time” was not only an elite player but also a charismatic leader. His work in mentoring young athletes has solidified his place as a respected icon.
9. Roger Staubach (QB, 1969-1979)
A true gentleman of the game, Staubach’s leadership and military service earned him universal respect.
8. Ed Reed (S, 2002-2013)
One of the smartest defensive players ever, Reed’s work ethic and football IQ made him a highly respected leader in the locker room.
7. Bruce Smith (DE, 1985-2003)
The NFL’s all-time sack leader was a true professional and leader, respected by everyone who played against him.
6. Tony Gonzalez (TE, 1997-2013)
Gonzalez redefined the tight end position while being one of the most humble and respected players in the game.
5. Jerry Rice (WR, 1985-2004)
The greatest receiver of all time was also one of the hardest-working players ever, earning him universal respect.
4. John Elway (QB, 1983-1998)
Elway’s leadership, toughness, and ability to win on the biggest stage made him one of the most admired quarterbacks in history.
3. Joe Montana (QB, 1979-1994)
“Joe Cool” was the epitome of clutch, and his quiet leadership earned the respect of fans, teammates, and opponents alike.
2. Ronnie Lott (S, 1981-1994)
Lott’s toughness, leadership, and commitment to the game made him one of the most respected defensive players of all time.
Read More: 30 College Football Stars Who Struggled in the NFL
1. Vince Lombardi (Coach, 1954-1970)
Though not a player, Lombardi’s name is synonymous with excellence and leadership. His influence on the game, as well as his emphasis on character, makes him the most respected figure in NFL history.
Read More: Ranking the 25 Most Likable NFL Stars Playing Now
