Ranking the 20 Most Respected Veterans in Baseball History

Baseball has always been a sport that reveres its elder statesmen—those players who not only put together long, productive careers but also earned the admiration of teammates, opponents, and fans alike. These veterans were more than just stat-sheet stuffers; they were clubhouse leaders, role models, and living proof that you could age gracefully in a game defined by failure.

Some were iron men who stuck around for decades. Others left such a lasting impression that their presence alone elevated an entire franchise. From quiet legends to vocal captains, here are 20 of the most respected veterans in baseball history.

20. Jim Kaat

Jim Kaat
Wikimedia Commons

Jim Kaat pitched in parts of four decades and never stopped being a professional’s professional. Teammates respected his work ethic, and opponents knew he always came prepared.

19. Torii Hunter

Torii Hunter
Flickr

Torii Hunter brought energy, leadership, and defense everywhere he went. He was the glue guy in every clubhouse and had a knack for mentoring younger players.

18. Julio Franco

Julio Franco
Wikimedia Commons

Julio Franco somehow made it to the big leagues in four different decades. His dedication to health, fitness, and the craft of hitting made him a role model for generations.

17. Jamie Moyer

Jamie Moyer
Flickr

Jamie Moyer didn’t throw hard, but he threw forever. He outlasted plenty of power pitchers by knowing how to pitch and lead.

16. David Ross

David Ross
Wikimedia Commons

“Grandpa Rossy” became a cult hero late in his career, but his veteran presence always carried weight. He was the perfect teammate and the kind of catcher pitchers trusted instinctively.

15. C.C. Sabathia

C.C. Sabathia
Flickr

C.C. grew into a clubhouse leader over time, blending authenticity with wisdom. His transformation from a power pitcher to a crafty veteran earned respect across the league.

14. Mark Buehrle

Mark Buehrle
Wikimedia Commons

Mark Buehrle wasn’t flashy, but he was consistent, dependable, and well-liked by everyone. His no-nonsense demeanor made him a quiet anchor in every rotation.

13. Chase Utley

Chase Utley
Wikimedia Commons

Nicknamed “The Man” in Philly for a reason, Chase Utley played hard, said little, and let his actions speak for themselves. Opponents may not have loved playing against him, but they respected the hell out of him.

12. Andy Pettitte

Andy Pettitte
Wikimedia Commons

Andy Pettitte had the kind of calm, veteran presence teams dream of in October. He never sought the spotlight but always delivered in the big moments.

11. Tim Wakefield

Tim Wakefield
Flickr

Knuckleballers are already unicorns, but Tim Wakefield was also a rare breed of teammate. His loyalty to Boston and willingness to do whatever the team needed made him beloved in every dugout.

10. Darren Oliver

Darren Oliver
Wikimedia Commons

Darren Oliver flew under the radar, but he played for three decades and was considered one of the most respected teammates in baseball. He embraced every role and did it with class.

9. Ichiro Suzuki

Ichiro Suzuki in action, wearing helmet
Wikimedia Commons

Ichiro brought a meticulous, zen-like discipline to the game. Even in his 40s, teammates watched him with the awe of someone who had mastered his craft.

8. Bartolo Colon

Bartolo Colon
Flickr

Big Sexy was more than just a fan favorite—he was a baseball lifer who kept things light but always competed. His durability and reinvention late in his career were quietly admirable.

7. Jason Giambi

Jason Giambi
Wikimedia Commons

Jason Giambi’s leadership extended well beyond the box score. Younger teammates gravitated toward him, and his honesty and openness made him a locker room favorite.

6. Albert Pujols

Albert Pujols
Flickr

Pujols had one of the greatest peaks ever, but his career longevity and mentorship made him a revered veteran in his later years. He gave back to the game as much as he took from it.

5. Miguel Cabrera

Miguel Cabrera
Wikimedia Commons

Miggy’s joy, work ethic, and hitting ability made him a clubhouse legend. Everyone respected how he carried himself through the ups and downs.

4. Cal Ripken Jr.

Cal Ripken Jr.
Wikimedia Commons

Iron Man defined what it meant to show up, do your job, and earn respect daily. He never made it about him, which made him beloved.

3. Mariano Rivera

Mariano Rivera throwing baseball on field
Wikimedia Commons

There may never be a more respected closer than Mariano. He let his cutter—and his humility—do all the talking.

Read More: 15 NFL Veterans Who Led by Example, Not Volume

2. Clayton Kershaw

Clayton Kershaw
Wikimedia Commons

Kershaw’s blend of greatness and groundedness has made him universally admired. He’s a once-in-a-generation talent who still feels like the guy next door.

Read More: 10 Veteran Golfers Who’ve Become Mentors to the Next Generation

1. Derek Jeter

Derek Jeter
Flickr

Jeter was the blueprint for what it meant to be a respected veteran. He led by example, treated everyone with dignity, and made it cool to be all class, all the time.

Read More: 15 MLB Veterans Who Took Young Teammates Under Their Wing

Related Articles
castawaystudios_an_action_shot_of_an_NHL_game_close_up_of_the_i_cc6d3bf8-69a1-45cf-bd2a-5e915a96e9fd
NHL Playoff Update: Game Moments, Injuries and Top Plays
The 2025 NHL Playoffs are no place for the timid, and Thursday night delivered a double dose of drama. ...
Read More
Sad NFL player
10 NFL Players Blacklisted From the League
Some players, despite their talent, find themselves blacklisted due to off-field controversies, legal...
Read More
Bryson DeChambeau
Ranking the 15 Most Emotionally Volatile Golfers Ever
Whether it’s competitive passion or just plain fury, these 15 golfers have become famous (or infamous)...
Read More

As an Amazon Associate, The Quick Report earns from qualifying purchases.

Part of the Castaway Studios media network.