Baseball has had plenty of stars, but only a select few earn universal respect from players, coaches, and fans alike. Whether it was their leadership, work ethic, class, or ability to deliver in the biggest moments, these players left an impact that went beyond the numbers.
Here are the 18 most respected players in MLB history—the legends who earned admiration from everyone in the game.
18. Derek Jeter
The Captain was all about winning, leadership, and delivering in the clutch. Whether you loved or hated the Yankees, you couldn’t help but respect the way Jeter carried himself on and off the field.
17. Stan Musial
Musial was one of the most consistent hitters ever, but he was just as great off the field. Known as one of the nicest guys in baseball history, “Stan the Man” was beloved by fans, teammates, and even rivals.
16. Cal Ripken Jr.
The Iron Man defined durability, playing in 2,632 consecutive games. His work ethic, quiet leadership, and commitment to the game made him one of the most admired players ever.
15. Ichiro Suzuki
Ichiro played the game with a level of skill and professionalism that won over both American and Japanese baseball fans. He had a relentless work ethic, a one-of-a-kind batting style, and a personality that made him impossible to dislike.
14. Tony Gwynn
Gwynn was one of the greatest pure hitters ever, but he was also one of the classiest. He stayed loyal to San Diego his entire career, always played the game the right way, and was universally admired for his humble nature.
13. Jackie Robinson
Jackie Robinson changed baseball forever, breaking the color barrier while playing at an elite level. The way he handled hatred and pressure with class, grace, and sheer talent made him one of the most respected athletes in history.
12. Albert Pujols
Pujols was a force at the plate and a leader in the clubhouse. He combined raw power with a strong sense of humility, making him one of the most respected players of his generation.
11. Hank Aaron
Aaron endured racism and threats while chasing Babe Ruth’s home run record but carried himself with nothing but grace. He finished with 755 home runs and more class than just about anyone in the history of the sport.
10. Ted Williams
Williams was one of the best hitters of all time, but he also served in both World War II and the Korean War. His dedication to his craft and his country made him a legend both on and off the field.
9. Joe Mauer
Mauer was a homegrown superstar who stayed loyal to the Twins and played the game the right way. He was known for his quiet professionalism and being one of the best-hitting catchers in baseball history.
8. Ozzie Smith
The Wizard of Oz turned defense into an art form, and his backflips onto the field made him a fan favorite. He played the game with a rare combination of skill, energy, and respect for baseball history.
7. Buster Posey
Posey led the Giants to three World Series titles and did it with a calm, steady presence. He earned admiration for his leadership, work behind the plate, and the way he carried himself throughout his career.
6. Lou Gehrig
Gehrig was a superstar, but his humility and courage in the face of ALS made him an icon. His “Luckiest Man on the Face of the Earth” speech remains one of the most moving moments in sports history.
5. Roberto Clemente
Clemente was a Hall of Fame player, but his humanitarian work made him an even bigger legend. His tragic passing while delivering aid to earthquake victims only cemented his place as one of the most respected athletes ever.
4. Willie Mays
Mays played the game with a joy and excellence that earned him universal admiration. The Say Hey Kid had five-tool talent and carried himself like a true ambassador of the game.
3. Clayton Kershaw
Kershaw has dominated for over a decade while remaining humble and respected by everyone in the league. His leadership, charity work, and quiet determination make him one of the game’s modern-day greats.
2. Mike Trout
Trout is a once-in-a-generation talent who somehow manages to stay humble despite being the best player of his era. He plays hard every single game and lets his performance speak for itself.
Read More: Ranking the 30 Most Respected Players in NFL History
1. Yadier Molina
Few players have commanded more respect from teammates, opponents, and fans than Yadi. A defensive genius, a leader in every clubhouse he stepped into, and a true warrior on the field, Molina is the definition of what it means to be respected in baseball.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Likeable MLB Players Ever
