The 13 Most Overrated Franchises in All of Sports

Let’s face it, not all sports franchises live up to the hype surrounding them. Some organizations are lauded for their past, resources, or star power — yet when it comes to delivering results, they consistently fall short. So, with that, let’s rank the most overrated franchises in all of sports. 

New York Mets 

Openverse

There’s no question the Mets have a loyal fanbase and play in the media capital of the world, but their history is riddled with missed opportunities. Despite their two World Series wins, the franchise has often been overshadowed by their crosstown rivals, the New York Yankees.

Cleveland Browns

Openverse

The Cleveland Browns have a storied history, but it’s mostly from the pre-Super Bowl era. But, since then, the franchise has been synonymous with mediocrity and draft busts. 

Toronto Maple Leafs

Openverse

The Maple Leafs have such a rich history, but their last Stanley Cup victory came in 1967. In fact, decades of playoff disappointments have made their lofty reputation feel undeserved.

Notre Dame Fighting Irish

Openverse

Notre Dame’s legacy is undeniable, but the team’s modern-day relevance is questionable. And, while they command national attention, they often fall short in marquee bowl games and the College Football Playoff. Sorry, Fighting Irish fans!

New York Knicks

Openverse

The New York Knicks are one of the most valuable franchises in the NBA, but let’s be honest for a second, their on-court success has been nearly non-existent in recent years. In fact, their last championship was in 1973!

Washington Commanders

Openverse

This franchise once enjoyed complete NFL dominance in the 1980s and early 1990s. However, the past three decades have been marred by poor ownership. In their defense, it does look like things are turning around for the franchise, thanks to the arrival of quarterback Jayden Daniels.

Dallas Cowboys

Openverse

Known as “America’s Team,” the Dallas Cowboys have a massive following and a wealth of resources. However, their playoff success has been minimal since their 1990s dynasty. They talk a big game, but the truth is they’ve been mediocre for almost 30 years. 

Paris Saint-Germain

Openverse

PSG has dominated Ligue 1 thanks to its financial backing and star-studded rosters, but they’ve yet to win the Champions League despite their resources.  

Chicago Cubs

Openverse

The Chicago Cubs broke their infamous 108-year championship drought in 2016, but their reputation as “lovable losers” often masked decades of ineptitude. 

Manchester United 

Openverse

Manchester United’s glory days under Sir Alex Ferguson made them one of the most recognized sports brands in the world. However, since his departure, their inconsistent performances and questionable management decisions have diminished their status as an elite club.

Read More: The 29 Most Successful NFL Seasons Ever

Philadelphia 76ers 

Openverse

The 76ers are a historic franchise with an enthusiastic fanbase, but let’s face it, there’s been a lot of overpromising and underdelivering happening. Despite getting talent like Joel Embiid, they’ve struggled to make deep playoff runs.

Read More: The 10 Most Overrated Sports Cars of All Time

Los Angeles Lakers

Openverse

The Los Angeles Lakers have an incredible 17 championships, but their reputation sometimes overshadows their flaws. In fact, over the years, the franchise has relied heavily on acquiring superstars rather than consistent team-building.

Read More: The 11 Most Overrated Coaches in College Football History

New York Yankees 

Openverse

The New York Yankees have won a whopping 27 World Series titles, which is incredible. However, their last championship was in 2009. Yes, they did make the World Series this year, but for a team that is so iconic (and with so much money), they should be winning titles more consistently. 

Read More: These Are the 10 Most Expensive Sports Teams in the World

Related Articles
Mar 30, 1995; Chicago, IL, USA; Chicago Bulls guard Michael Jordan (45) talks with forward Scottie Pippen (33) after a timeout from the game against the Boston Celtics at Chicago Stadium. The Bulls beat the Celtics 100-82. Mandatory Credit: Matthew Emmons-Imagn Images
The 30 Coolest NBA Duos of All Time
These NBA pairs brought energy, swagger, and star power every time they shared the floor.
Read More
Oct 28, 2024; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; New York Giants quarterback Daniel Jones (8) runs the ball against the Pittsburgh Steelers during the fourth quarter at Acrisure Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images
The 15 Most Awkward Runners in NFL History
Whether it was stiff limbs or a complete lack of coordination, these 15 players made you do a double-take...
Read More
Payne Stewart
12 Golf Greats Who’d Be Totally Exposed on Modern Courses
Whether it’s the equipment, the competition, or the course design, these golf greats would have a rough...
Read More
Oct 29, 2000; Tampa, FL, USA; FILE PHOTO; Minnesota Vikings receiver (80) Cris Carter in action against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers at Raymond James Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Photo by Paul Chapman-USA TODAY Sports
20 NFL Players Who Changed Teams and Instantly Leveled Up
From forgotten backups to franchise cornerstones, these 20 players proved that sometimes all it takes...
Read More
Boston Red Sox designated hitter David Ortiz (34) tosses the pine tar rag before hitting in the fourth inning against the Cleveland Indians during game three of the 2016 ALDS playoff baseball series at Fenway Park.
14 MLB Players With Animalistic Strength
From legendary home run kings to modern-day powerhouses, this list celebrates 14 MLB players whose strength...
Read More
Apr 9, 2018; San Antonio, TX, USA; San Antonio Spurs shooting guard Manu Ginobili (20) reacts after a shot against the Sacramento Kings during the second half at AT&T Center. Mandatory Credit: Soobum Im-Imagn Images
16 NBA Stars Who Were Better as Sidekicks
Whether it was playing next to a dominant big man or an all-time great, here are 16 NBA stars who proved...
Read More

As an Amazon Associate, The Quick Report earns from qualifying purchases.

Part of the Castaway Studios media network.