The 15 Most Overhyped College Football Teams of the Past 20 Years

Every college football season kicks off with a fresh batch of hype—preseason polls, glossy media guides, and bold declarations about who’s “back.” And while some teams live up to the buzz, others crash and burn before the leaves even start to fall.

Whether it was because of returning starters, flashy recruits, or a new coaching hire, these teams were supposed to be national contenders. Instead, they fell flat and became cautionary tales about believing the preseason hype too quickly.

15. 2017 Florida State

Florida State Seminoles football Team
Flickr

With a top ranking and loads of talent, this team entered the year with title talk swirling. But things unraveled quickly, and the hype faded faster than a three-and-out.

14. 2009 Ole Miss

Ole Miss vs Arkansas, 2010
Wikimedia Commons

They cracked the top 10 early and were billed as a dark horse playoff threat. Then reality hit, and the season turned into a disappointment sandwich.

13. 2021 North Carolina

North Carolina Tar Heels
Flickr

With a rising star at quarterback and big expectations, this was supposed to be a breakout year. Instead, they stumbled and never found their footing.

12. 2005 Tennessee

Tennessee Volunteers football Team
Flickr

The hype was sky-high heading into the season, but the offense sputtered and things went sideways. By the end, fans were wondering what happened to all that promise.

11. 2012 USC

USC Trojans football
Flickr

This team started the season in the top 5 with a Heisman favorite at quarterback. By year’s end, they were barely bowl-eligible and the dream had completely derailed.

10. 2020 Penn State

Penn State Nittany Lions football Team
Flickr

Touted as a potential playoff team, they opened the year with big expectations. But a brutal start to the season had them out of the picture in a hurry.

9. 2016 Notre Dame

Notre Dame Fighting Irish football
Flickr

The preseason buzz was loud in South Bend, but the losses piled up fast. A team with so much potential ended up limping to the finish line.

8. 2018 Miami

Miami Hurricanes football
Flickr

They came into the year with swagger, turnover chains, and big talk. But the product on the field didn’t come close to matching the preseason energy.

7. 2014 South Carolina

South Carolina Gamecocks football team Match
Flickr

With momentum from strong seasons before, this team looked ready to take the next step. Instead, it was a step back and then some.

6. 2007 Michigan

Michigan Wolverines football
Flickr

The hype was real, but the upset in Week 1 set the tone for a rough ride. What was supposed to be a title run turned into a year to forget.

5. 2015 Auburn

Auburn Tigers
Flickr

With a top-tier defense and a Heisman hopeful under center, Auburn had big dreams. But the execution just wasn’t there, and the season fizzled.

4. 2001 Oregon State

Oregon State Beavers vs Wisconsin Badgers
Wikimedia Commons

They entered the year with sky-high expectations and top rankings. It didn’t take long for things to go sideways and the hype to vanish.

3. 2019 Nebraska

Nebraska Cornhuskers
Wikimedia Commons

A trendy pick to win their division, Nebraska was suddenly everyone’s favorite sleeper. But they hit snooze early and never woke up.

Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Overrated NFL Wide Receivers Playing Now

2. 2010 Texas

Texas Longhorns
Wikimedia Commons

Coming off recent success, the Longhorns were expected to reload and contend. Instead, they spent the season figuring out how things went so wrong.

Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Overconfident Fanbases in College Football

1. 2008 Georgia

Georgia Bulldogs
Flickr

They started the year ranked No. 1 and looked loaded on both sides of the ball. But the season was a rollercoaster of underwhelming results and unmet expectations.

Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Beloved College Football Programs

Related Articles
Jun 20, 2025; Uncasville, Connecticut, USA; Dallas Wings guard Paige Bueckers (5) reacts after a play against the Connecticut Sun in the second half at Mohegan Sun Arena. Mandatory Credit: David Butler II-Imagn Images
Paige Bueckers Breaks WNBA Record, Surpassing Caitlin Clark
Paige Bueckers Outpaces Clark to Make WNBA History Paige Bueckers and Caitlin Clark are widely viewed...
Read More
Apr 4, 2024; Cleveland, OH, USA; South Carolina Gamecocks coach Dawn Staley (left) and Iowa Hawkeyes guard Caitlin Clark pose react after being selected as the AP Coach and Player of the Year at a press conference at Rocket Mortgage FieldHouse. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports
Dawn Staley Highlights Caitlin Clark’s One Major Weakness
Even Legends Like Caitlin Clark Have Weak Spots, Says Dawn Staley Dawn Staley has faced Caitlin Clark...
Read More
Jun 17, 2025; Indianapolis, Indiana, USA; Indiana Fever guard Sophie Cunningham (8) and Connecticut Sun guard Jacy Sheldon (4) get into a fight in the second half at Gainbridge Fieldhouse. Mandatory Credit: Trevor Ruszkowski-Imagn Images
Sophie Cunningham Gets NFL Shoutout After Sticking Up for Caitlin Clark
Sophie Cunningham’s Loyalty Sparks NFL-Level Respect Sophie Cunningham may have been ejected, fined,...
Read More

As an Amazon Associate, The Quick Report earns from qualifying purchases.

Part of the Castaway Studios media network.