Some quarterbacks throw darts. Others scramble like magicians. And then there are the ones who never quite get their due—no matter how talented, clutch, or unique they are, people can’t seem to wrap their heads around them.
Whether it’s a few bad years, a polarizing personality, or simply being ahead of their time, these quarterbacks were never fully appreciated. Here are 15 QBs who were constantly misread, misjudged, or just plain misunderstood.
15. Kirk Cousins
Kirk Cousins has been the poster child for the “yeah, but” conversation for years. He’s been consistent and productive, yet everyone treats him like a placeholder waiting to be replaced.
14. Jake Plummer
Jake Plummer was a gritty, unorthodox gamer who didn’t fit the NFL mold. People saw his wild playstyle and forgot just how often he found ways to win.
13. Tony Romo
Tony Romo was often blamed for the Cowboys’ failures, but he consistently led mediocre rosters into contention. His late-game turnovers made headlines, while his brilliance in keeping Dallas relevant went largely unnoticed.
12. Jeff Garcia
Jeff Garcia never looked like your typical NFL star, and that always seemed to work against him. All he did was make Pro Bowls, win games, and get criticized for not being flashy enough.
11. Cam Newton
Cam Newton was larger than life—physically and emotionally, which rubbed some folks the wrong way. But behind the dab celebrations and Superman poses was a guy who took an absolute beating while carrying the Panthers.
10. Jay Cutler
Jay Cutler’s aloof demeanor made people assume he didn’t care, which couldn’t be further from the truth. His cannon arm and fearlessness often got overlooked because he didn’t pander to fans or media.
9. Rich Gannon
Rich Gannon didn’t peak until his mid-30s, which led many to write him off early. By the time he was shredding defenses and winning MVPs, most people still treated him like a backup.
8. Donovan McNabb
Donovan McNabb was a winner who played in five NFC Championship Games, yet he never seemed to get the full respect he earned. He was overshadowed by criticism, even when he was clearly one of the top quarterbacks of his era.
7. Boomer Esiason
Boomer Esiason had a big arm, big mouth, and big-time game—but people often focused more on the second part. He was a league MVP who led the Bengals to the Super Bowl, but is often overlooked in quarterback conversations.
6. Michael Vick
Michael Vick revolutionized the position, but his off-field issues will always dominate his story. Even after his comeback, many refused to acknowledge the growth he made both on and off the field.
5. Matthew Stafford
Matthew Stafford spent a decade in Detroit putting up monster numbers on mostly terrible teams. Because the Lions never won big, people just assumed he wasn’t elite—until the Rams handed him a Super Bowl ring.
4. Jim Everett
Jim Everett had the tools, the stats, and the playoff appearances, but one unfortunate interview moment haunted his legacy. That “soft” label never fit the guy who stood tall in a brutal era of football.
3. Lamar Jackson
Lamar Jackson hears it all—he’s a running back, he can’t throw, he won’t last. Meanwhile, he’s a former MVP who’s redefined what it means to be a dual-threat quarterback.
Read More: 18 Baseball Legends Who Were Anything But Beloved
2. Philip Rivers
Philip Rivers was fiery, funky, and always a little unconventional, which made him a target. But you can’t fake over 63,000 yards and 400 touchdowns—he was as real as it gets.
Read More: 10 Reasons Lamar Jackson Is Actually the Best NFL Quarterback
1. Randall Cunningham
Randall Cunningham was doing Lamar Jackson things before the world was ready for it. His athleticism was otherworldly, but his play was often overshadowed by outdated expectations of what a quarterback should be.
Read More: Bo Jackson Gives Up $21 Million in Family Extortion Case
