Quarterbacks often get all the attention, good or bad. But some rise above the noise to become universally beloved figures, earning admiration from fans, teammates, and even rivals.
Whether it’s because of their talent, personality, or how they carried themselves in big moments, these 15 quarterbacks hold a special place in football fans’ hearts. From comeback kings to community legends, here are the most loved signal-callers the game has ever seen.
15. Joe Burrow
He might still be early in his career, but Joe Burrow has already become one of the league’s most admired quarterbacks. Between his swagger, comeback from injury, and bond with Cincinnati, fans can’t help but root for him.
14. Doug Flutie
Doug Flutie wasn’t the biggest guy on the field, but his heart and hustle made him a fan favorite wherever he went. His underdog vibe and iconic Hail Mary cemented his place in football folklore.
13. Drew Brees
Drew Brees turned the Saints into a perennial contender and gave New Orleans hope after Hurricane Katrina. His leadership and community impact have made him one of the most respected players of his generation.
12. Kurt Warner
Kurt Warner’s rags-to-riches story is one of the most inspirational in sports. Fans loved every second of his journey from stocking grocery shelves to winning a Super Bowl.
11. Fran Tarkenton
Before the era of mobile quarterbacks, Fran Tarkenton did everything with his legs and arms. His improvisational style and consistency made him beloved in Minnesota and beyond.
10. Peyton Manning
Peyton Manning was a surgeon on the field and a comedian off it. Fans adored him not just for his elite play, but also for his commercials, charm, and aw-shucks likability.
9. Jim Kelly
Jim Kelly never won a Super Bowl, but his toughness and perseverance made him legendary in Buffalo. He’s also inspired off the field with his courageous battle against cancer inspired him off the field.
8. Patrick Mahomes
Patrick Maho’s visibility, humility, and electric playmaking. He’s made Kansas City a powerhouse and won over fans everywhere with his likable personality and highlight-reel moments.
7. Roger Staubach
Roger Staubach was the original Captain America. A Navy veteran and Cowboys icon, he embodied leadership and class throughout his career.
6. Dan Marino
Dan Marino was universally loved for his golden arm and fiery competitiveness, even without a ring. Dolphins fans still talk about him like he played yesterday.
5. Josh Allen
In just a handful of years, Josh Allen has won over the hearts of Bills Mafia and almost every neutral NFL fan. His humble demeanor, powerful game, and dedication to Buffalo have made him a modern favorite.
4. Russell Wilson
Russell Wilson’s positivity, work ethic, and faith made him a beloved figure in Seattle during the peak Legion of Boom years. He brought the city its first Super Bowl and carried himself like a professional.
3. Tom Brady
Yes, some hated him for all the winning, but he was deeply loved by Patriots fans and respected by nearly everyone else. Over time, Brady’s longevity and excellence turned skepticism into appreciation.
Read More: Unsung Heroes: The 30 Best Backup Quarterbacks in NFL History
2. Tony Romo
Tony Romo wasn’t just Dallas’s quarterback—he was the team’s heart during a chaotic era. Fans loved his grit, clutch moments, and now, charm in the broadcast booth.
Read More: 10 Vain Quarterbacks Who Loved the Mirror as Much as the Playbook
1. Steve Young
Steve Young had to follow Joe Montana, and somehow made fans love him just as much. He’s universally loved with his thrilling playstyle, humility, and Hall of Fame career.
