Baseball is full of larger-than-life personalities, but some players just have that special charm.
Whether it’s their on-field magic, infectious energy, or the way they make the game more fun, these guys earned a permanent place in fans’ hearts. Let’s rank the 15 most likeable MLB players of all time!
15. Joe Mauer
Hometown hero? Check. MVP? Check. Humble, hardworking, and one of the best-hitting catchers ever? Absolutely. Mauer spent his entire career with the Twins and never had an ego, making him one of baseball’s most respected stars.
14. Anthony Rizzo
Rizzo helped break the Cubs’ 108-year curse, and he did it with a smile on his face. Whether he’s hyping up teammates, cracking jokes, or making a clutch play, he’s the kind of guy you want on your team. His charity work and love for the game only add to his likeability.
13. Bo Jackson
Bo knew baseball. Bo knew football. And Bo knew how to win people over. His insane athleticism made him a must-watch player, but his humble, soft-spoken nature off the field made him even more beloved.
12. Ichiro Suzuki
Ichiro was a magician with the bat and one of the smoothest players to ever step on a baseball field. But it wasn’t just his game—his sense of humor, charisma, and respect for the sport made him a fan favorite around the world.
11. Trevor Hoffman
Closers usually have intensity, but Hoffman had class. He dominated on the mound with 601 career saves, but he was always humble, gracious, and one of the most respected players in baseball. Plus, “Hells Bells” as his entrance song? Legendary.
10. Tony Gwynn
Few players represented their city better than Tony Gwynn did for San Diego. He was a hitting machine, a team-first player, and one of the most genuine people to ever play the game. He never left the Padres, proving that loyalty still exists in sports.
9. Mookie Betts
Mookie has it all—talent, swag, and a personality that makes everyone love him. Whether he’s bowling a perfect game (because of course he does) or robbing home runs, he makes baseball more fun. Dodgers and Red Sox fans both adore him, which says a lot.
8. Ozzie Smith
Ozzie Smith didn’t just play baseball—he entertained. The backflipping, glove-wielding shortstop was one of the best defenders ever, and his joy for the game was contagious. You couldn’t watch him play without smiling.
7. Jim Thome
Thome hit 612 home runs, but he never acted like a superstar. He was one of the nicest guys in baseball, respected by everyone, and always played the game the right way. Even pitchers who gave up moonshots to him couldn’t help but like the guy.
6. David Ortiz
Big Papi was larger than life, and baseball was better because of him. Whether he was crushing clutch homers, giving epic postgame speeches, or making everyone laugh, Ortiz was impossible not to like. His personality was just as big as his bat.
5. Derek Jeter
Jeter was the face of baseball for two decades, and somehow, he managed to stay cool under the spotlight. He was professional, clutch, and handled the pressure of New York like a legend. Even Red Sox fans (secretly) respected him.
4. Cal Ripken Jr.
The Iron Man was the definition of a role model. He broke records without ego, played 2,632 straight games, and always carried himself with pure class. Few players have ever been more respected.
3. Ken Griffey Jr.
Griffey made baseball cool. The backwards hat, the sweetest swing in history, and his effortless swagger made him a fan favorite everywhere. He played with joy, never took himself too seriously, and just made baseball better.
Read More: 10 NFL Players Who Were Villains on the Field but Likeable Off It
2. Hank Aaron
Hank Aaron was pure class. He broke records with quiet confidence, handled immense pressure with dignity, and was a role model for generations. Few players have ever been more universally loved and respected.
Read More: Ranking All 32 NFL Starting Quarterbacks From Least to Most Likeable
1. Jackie Robinson
Jackie Robinson wasn’t just likeable—he was legendary. He changed the game forever, endured unimaginable pressure, and carried himself with grace through it all. His impact on baseball and society goes beyond stats, making him the most respected and admired player in MLB history.
Read More: Ranking the Best MLB Players of the 1980s
