The 10 Most Heartbreaking Losses in NFL History

Every NFL team experiences tough losses, but some are so gut-wrenching that they haunt fanbases for generations. Whether it was a last-second blunder, a historic collapse, or a championship that slipped away, these losses left players and fans alike in total devastation.

From Super Bowl heartbreaks to playoff meltdowns, here are the 10 most heartbreaking losses in NFL history.

10. The No-Call – New Orleans Saints vs. Los Angeles Rams (2018 NFC Championship)

Rams cornerback hits Saints receiver
Wikipedia

Saints fans are still furious over the blatant pass interference that wasn’t called late in the fourth quarter. Instead of a chance to ice the game, New Orleans had to settle for a field goal, and the Rams went on to win in overtime—sending them to the Super Bowl on one of the worst officiating blunders ever.

9. Super Bowl XXXVIII – Carolina Panthers vs. New England Patriots (2004)

Carolina Panthers vs. New England Patriots
Flickr

The Panthers clawed their way back into a thrilling game, tying it 29-29 with just over a minute left. But a costly kickoff out of bounds handed Tom Brady great field position, and Adam Vinatieri did what he does best—drilling a game-winning field goal to crush Carolina’s dreams.

8. The Minneapolis Miracle – New Orleans Saints vs. Minnesota Vikings (2017 Divisional Round)

New Orleans Saints vs. Minnesota Vikings
Flickr

The Saints had just taken the lead with 25 seconds left and looked ready to advance. Then Stefon Diggs caught a last-second, sideline tiptoe touchdown, leaving the entire Saints defense—and their fanbase—completely stunned.

7. The Fumble – Cleveland Browns vs. Denver Broncos (1987 AFC Championship)

Cleveland Browns vs. Denver Broncos
Wikimedia Commons

The Browns were on the verge of their first Super Bowl appearance when running back Earnest Byner was stripped of the ball at the goal line. Instead of a game-tying touchdown, Cleveland walked away with yet another crushing defeat at the hands of John Elway.

6. The Catch II – Green Bay Packers vs. San Francisco 49ers (1998 Wild Card Round)

Green Bay Packers vs. San Francisco 49ers
Flickr

Brett Favre had just led a heroic drive to put the Packers ahead with under two minutes left. But Steve Young and Terrell Owens had other plans, connecting on a dramatic last-second touchdown that left Green Bay heartbroken.

5. The Music City Miracle – Buffalo Bills vs. Tennessee Titans (1999 Wild Card Round)

Daren Bates on the sidelines during a game against the Buffalo Bills
Wikimedia Commons

The Bills thought they had won after kicking a go-ahead field goal with 16 seconds left. Then the Titans pulled off one of the most controversial and improbable plays ever—Frank Wycheck’s lateral (or forward pass, if you ask Bills fans) to Kevin Dyson, who took it to the house and sent Buffalo into a tailspin.

4. Super Bowl XXV – Buffalo Bills vs. New York Giants (1991)

Buffalo Bills vs. New York Giants
Flickr

Scott Norwood’s 47-yard field goal attempt sailed just wide right in the final seconds, sealing a painful 20-19 loss for Buffalo. This heartbreaking miss kicked off a four-year stretch of Super Bowl defeats for the Bills, making it even more brutal.

3. The Fail Mary – Green Bay Packers vs. Seattle Seahawks (2012)

Green Bay Packers vs. Seattle Seahawks
Wikimedia Commons

Replacement referees completely botched the final play, awarding Seattle a game-winning touchdown on what was clearly an interception by Green Bay’s M.D. Jennings. The blown call caused so much outrage that the NFL had no choice but to end the referee lockout immediately.

Read More: Ranking the 20 Most Heated NFL Player Feuds of All Time

2. Super Bowl XLIX – Seattle Seahawks vs. New England Patriots (2015)

Seattle Seahawks vs. New England Patriots
Flickr

With the game on the line and Marshawn Lynch in the backfield, Seattle decided to throw the ball at the one-yard line—and Malcolm Butler made them regret it forever. His shocking interception sealed the win for the Patriots, while Seahawks fans are still shaking their heads over why they didn’t just run it.

Read More: 20 NFL Stars Who Clashed With Their Head Coach

1. 28-3 – Atlanta Falcons vs. New England Patriots (Super Bowl LI, 2017)

New England Patriots defeat the Atlanta Falcons
Wikipedia

No loss in NFL history has been as epic—and painful—as the Falcons’ legendary Super Bowl collapse. Atlanta had a 28-3 lead in the third quarter, only to watch Tom Brady orchestrate the greatest comeback ever, leaving Falcons fans with a nightmare they’ll never escape.

Read More: Every NFL Team’s Most Crushing Playoff Loss, Ranked

Related Articles
Jul 6, 2025; Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA; Chicago Sky forward Angel Reese (5) comes down with the rebound in a pack of Minnesota Lynx players in the fourth quarter at Target Center. Mandatory Credit: Matt Blewett-Imagn Images
Angel Reese Slams WNBA Refs With One-Word Tweet After Foul Controversy
Angel Reese sounds off on WNBA officiating after a rough game vs the Lynx, calling the referees "diabolical"...
Read More
Jul 3, 2025; Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA; Minnesota Lynx head coach Cheryl Reeve looks on against the Washington Mystics in the second half at Target Center. Mandatory Credit: Jesse Johnson-Imagn Images
Cheryl Reeve Slams WNBA All-Star Snubs After Caitlin Clark Decision
Cheryl Reeve questions WNBA All-Star selections, pointing to Lynx dominance and Caitlin Clark's inclusion...
Read More
Indiana Fever guard Sophie Cunningham (8) and Indiana Fever guard Aari McDonald (2) react to a call Thursday, July 3, 2025, during a game between the Indiana Fever and the Las Vegas Aces at Gainbridge Fieldhouse in Indianapolis.
LA Sparks Troll Sophie Cunningham After Win With Brutal Jab
The Sparks clapped back at Sophie Cunningham after beating the Fever, trolling her for controversial...
Read More

As an Amazon Associate, The Quick Report earns from qualifying purchases.

Part of the Castaway Studios media network.