Ranking the 20 Most “Dad Energy” MLB Stars Ever

Some players just have that unmistakable “dad energy.” You know the vibe: practical sneakers, a deep love of grilling, and the kind of steady presence that feels like they could fix your sink and also throw a complete game shutout. In the world of Major League Baseball, that dad energy shows up in different ways—whether it’s the veteran clubhouse leader, the guy who never skips postgame handshakes, or the one who seems a little too excited about his riding mower.

These are the MLB stars who felt like your buddy’s dad or the neighborhood coach with infinite life advice. From laid-back legends to no-nonsense field generals, here are 20 players who brought serious dad energy to the diamond.

20. Bartolo Colón

He pitched forever, smiled through it all, and ran the bases like someone late for a PTA meeting. Bartolo’s whole vibe screamed proud dad who brings orange slices to every game—even if he’s the one playing.

19. Paul Konerko

Konerko was calm, consistent, and never tried to be flashy. He felt like the kind of guy who would mow the lawn diagonally and teach you how to drive stick.

18. Chase Utley

Utley had that serious, no-fuss dad energy that didn’t need a lot of words. He’d quietly win the game and then make sure everyone packed up their gear properly.

17. Justin Turner

With his lumberjack beard and veteran leadership, Turner looked like a guy who grilled steaks year-round and gave inspirational speeches in the garage. He always had that “cool but stern Little League coach” aura.

16. Buster Posey

Posey was composed, polite, and always in control. He felt like the dad who insists on leaving for the airport five hours early.

15. Mark Buehrle

He worked fast, never complained, and made everything look simple. Classic dad behavior—no flash, just results.

14. Jim Thome

Thome had a permanently wholesome energy, like he’d help you with your science project and then hit a home run before dinner. He was everyone’s baseball dad, even during his playing days.

13. Dallas Keuchel

The beard, the demeanor, the pitching style—it was all very “I built this deck myself” energy. Keuchel always looked like he was about to host a barbecue for the whole neighborhood.

12. Todd Helton

Quiet, reliable, and loyal to one team for his whole career. Todd Helton gave off serious “family man with a pickup truck” energy.

11. Kyle Hendricks

Hendricks doesn’t throw hard, doesn’t talk much, and never gets rattled. He’s the kind of dad who just silently wins at everything and still picks you up from school right on time.

10. Adam Wainwright

Waino brought wisdom, patience, and a deep sense of responsibility to every team he played for. He felt like the dad who teaches Sunday school and also dominates your fantasy league.

9. John Lackey

With his permanent scowl and take-no-nonsense approach, Lackey was basically a grumpy but lovable baseball dad. He’d yell at you to hustle, then pat you on the back afterward.

8. Zack Greinke

Greinke’s quiet weirdness and blunt honesty scream dad who only speaks when it’s absolutely necessary—but when he does, it’s unforgettable. He’s the guy who says “good talk” after a one-word conversation.

7. Jason Varitek

He wore the C, managed egos, and wasn’t afraid to stand up for his guys. Total “neighborhood dad who still plays softball and umps your games on the weekend” energy.

6. David Ross

Even before he became a manager, he felt like a dad running the dugout. Now that he’s literally “Coach Ross,” the transformation is complete.

5. Torii Hunter

Always smiling, always mentoring, always leading. Hunter had big “take the whole team out for ice cream” vibes.

4. Mike Mussina

The Ivy League aura, the serious demeanor, the dad-glasses look—Mussina brought all the suburban father energy you could ask for. He seemed like a guy who’d help you with your taxes and critique your pitching mechanics in the same breath.

3. Derek Jeter

Jeter’s whole presence was mature, clean-cut, and composed. He was the “organized dad with the calendar on the fridge” of the Yankees for two decades.

2. Clayton Kershaw

Faithful, disciplined, and quietly dominant. Kershaw’s whole vibe screams “wake up early, read the paper, make the best pancakes on the block.”

Read More: 15 NBA Stars Who Were More Team Dad Than Team Diva

1. Cal Ripken Jr.

The Iron Man himself, Ripken, was the dad of all baseball dads. He showed up every single day, set the tone for everyone around him, and never asked for attention—just respect.

Read More: Ranking the 15 Funniest MLB Nicknames of All Time