Baseball is a game defined by strategy, but sometimes even the best managers make decisions that backfire, and badly. These critical moments often change the course of games, playoff series, and entire seasons. Here are five unforgettable examples where managerial calls cost MLB teams dearly.
5. Bobby Cox’s 1996 World Series Intentional Walk Gone Wrong
During Game 4 of the 1996 World Series, Braves manager Bobby Cox intentionally walked a dangerous hitter to face a perceived weaker batter. The plan backfired when the next batter launched a game-winning home run, shifting momentum and ultimately impacting the series outcome.
4. Tony La Russa’s 2011 ALDS Overuse of Chris Carpenter
In the 2011 ALDS, La Russa kept starting pitcher Chris Carpenter on the mound despite signs of fatigue. Carpenter’s performance dipped, leading to a critical loss against the Tampa Bay Rays. The Cardinals fell short that postseason, with questions lingering about the pitching manager’s decision.
Read More: MLB Managers Who Left a Lasting Legacy on the Game
3. Joe Maddon’s 2015 World Series Game 1 Bullpen Decision
Joe Maddon’s decision to use a tired closer against a hot hitter in Game 1 of the World Series cost the Cubs dearly. The Royals capitalized on the Manager bullpen misstep to come back and win the game, setting the tone for their eventual championship.
2. Lou Piniella’s 2003 ALCS Game 7 Pitching Change
In Game 7 against the Boston Red Sox, Piniella pulled starting pitcher Freddy Garcia earlier than expected. The move brought in less reliable relievers, allowing the Sox to rally. Boston went on to win the series, ending the Yankees’ postseason run and changing the course of both franchises.
1. Terry Collins and the 2016 Mets NLCS Game 5 Blunder
In a pivotal moment against the Dodgers, Mets manager Terry Collins left closer Jeurys Familia in to face Corey Seager despite signs of fatigue. Seager crushed a game-tying home run, swinging momentum to Los Angeles. The Mets lost that game and the series, missing a chance to reach the World Series.
In high-stakes baseball, a single MLB managerial decision can ripple through the season. While hindsight is 20/20, these moments remind fans and teams alike how razor-thin the margin between victory and defeat truly is.
