Baseball has a long, proud history of icons rising to greatness, but not everyone sticks the landing. Some stars shine bright and crash even harder, leaving fans stunned and legacies a bit tarnished.
Whether it was injuries, personal issues, or a sudden loss of magic, these 17 MLB icons flamed out in fashion, leaving everyone asking, “What happened?” From MVPs to once-untouchable pitchers, these unforgettable flameouts defined the phrase “fall from grace.”
17. Josh Hamilton
His talent was undeniable, but his off-field battles often overshadowed his play. Once the face of a franchise, he faded out in a cloud of disappointment.
16. Dontrelle Willis
The D-Train came on strong with flair and fire, but that train derailed fast. Control issues and inconsistency turned a promising career into a short-lived story.
15. Ryan Howard
He was a home run machine who terrified pitchers for a few dominant seasons. But injuries and a steep decline in production made his exit feel far too early.
14. Yasiel Puig
He burst onto the scene with swagger, energy, and cannon throws from the outfield. But drama, inconsistency, and off-field noise quickly overshadowed his potential.
13. Mark Prior
For a moment, he looked like the next great ace. But injuries kept him off the mound and ultimately robbed him of the career he was destined for.
12. Matt Harvey
“The Dark Knight” ruled New York for a hot minute, then fell just as dramatically. Injuries and off-field headlines turned him into a cautionary tale.
11. Andruw Jones
He was one of the best defensive center fielders ever, but his batting average plummeted later in his career. A strange final stretch made people forget just how elite he once was.
10. Eric Chavez
He was supposed to be a cornerstone in Oakland, but his body had other plans. Injuries piled up, and the consistency never came back.
9. Jason Bay
The hype was real when he arrived in Boston and then New York. Unfortunately, his production never followed, and the fall-off was fast.
8. Rick Ankiel
From pitching phenom to outfield reclamation project, his career was a rollercoaster. That arm never fully recovered—literally or figuratively.
7. Grady Sizemore
He had all the tools—power, speed, charisma. Then injuries stole years from him, and he never quite got them back.
6. Nomar Garciaparra
For a few years, he was toe-to-toe with Jeter and A-Rod. But injuries and inconsistency knocked him off the pedestal quicker than expected.
5. Jose Reyes
He was electric on the basepaths and beloved by Mets fans. But as his speed vanished, so did his impact, and some of his off-field drama didn’t help either.
4. Brandon Webb
He won a Cy Young and looked like a long-term ace. Then came the injuries, and his career was done just like that.
3. B.J. Upton
There was so much potential and hype, but his bat never met the expectations. A big contract didn’t help how quickly things unraveled.
Read More: 10 NFL Players Who Are Redefining Style on and off the Field
2. Chris Davis
From launching bombs to leading the league in strikeouts, his career arc was a wild ride. The fall-off was so sharp it felt surreal.
Read More: Ranking the 20 Biggest “Me First” Quarterbacks in League History
1. Tim Lincecum
He was must-watch TV and had a delivery fan imitate in their backyards. But when the velocity dipped, so did the dominance—and the end came way too fast.
Read More: 20 MLB Stars Who Got Exposed When They Switched Teams
