The Los Angeles Dodgers are at a breaking point. With 15 pitchers already on the injured list, the team is clinging to elite talent and bold decisions to keep their World Series hopes alive. At the heart of the storm? Shohei Ohtani, the $700 million two-way megastar who’s itching to return to the mound.
But not everyone thinks that’s a good idea.
A-Rod Issues a Stark Warning
MLB legend Alex Rodriguez recently sounded the alarm, cautioning the Dodgers against risking Ohtani’s arm in 2025.
“If Ohtani gets hurt and makes it to 15 [16] pitchers on the IL, the season is over,” A-Rod said. With two Tommy John surgeries and a recent shoulder scare on Ohtani’s resume, Rodriguez believes the Dodgers should play it safe: sit him until 2026 and give him a full offseason to reset physically and mentally.
In his eyes, the reward just isn’t worth the risk.
Smoltz Fires Back: “Let Him Pitch”
But Hall of Famer John Smoltz, who lived the grind of the pitcher’s life, completely disagrees. In a blunt rebuttal, Smoltz delivered a simple message:
“I do think they should pitch him, and I think that’s what he wants.”
To Smoltz, Ohtani’s identity as a two-way player is essential, and stalling his return may do more harm than good.
“Second half, he’ll start pitching… and next year could be the most complete year we’ve ever seen out of anybody in the history of our game,” he said.
Smoltz’s faith in Ohtani’s mental toughness, pitch arsenal, and competitive drive puts him firmly in the “unleash him” camp—and recent developments support that idea.
Ohtani’s Return Is Brewing
According to Dodgers manager Dave Roberts, Shohei Ohtani recently threw 44 pitches over three innings in a simulated game, allowing just one hit and one walk. Though Roberts joked his return before the All-Star break is “north of zero,” he emphasized patience in finding the right moment.
Still, the signs are there. Velocity’s rising. Stuff is sharp. The tension builds with each bullpen session, as the Dodgers weigh whether to risk it all, or unleash a potential October weapon.
Read More: Shohei Ohtani Falls Asleep in Dugout During Dodgers’ 18-2 Beatdown of Yankees
