College football is built on rivalries, big moments, and even bigger personalities—but sometimes, the off-field headlines start to overshadow the scoreboard. From coaching chaos to locker room tension and media circus vibes, some teams couldn’t get out of their way.
These 11 programs had the talent to win, but instead, they got caught up in the noise. Whether it was internal dysfunction or outside distractions, the drama took center stage—and the wins took a backseat.
11. 2020 Michigan Wolverines
A proud program with high expectations turned into a weekly soap opera under the bright lights of the COVID-19 season. Between blowout losses and Jim Harbaugh’s hot seat talk, it was hard to tell if football was even the main story.
10. 2017 Ole Miss Rebels
Scandal swirled around the program before the first whistle even blew, thanks to NCAA violations and Hugh Freeze’s infamous downfall. The team never stood a chance with all the noise drowning out any chance of momentum.
9. 2022 Texas A&M Aggies
With a top-ranked recruiting class came even higher expectations—and a full-blown mess. Between player suspensions, locker room issues, and a losing record, the hype train crashed hard.
8. 2010 USC Trojans
Still reeling from the fallout of NCAA sanctions, USC was stuck in limbo. Lane Kiffin brought attention, but not the kind that translated into wins or stability.
7. 2005 Tennessee Volunteers
Supposed to contend for the SEC crown, this squad unraveled quickly. On-field confusion and off-field turmoil made for a forgettable and frustrating year in Knoxville.
6. 2023 Colorado Buffaloes
Coach Prime brought swagger, soundbites, and a whole lot of media coverage. But after a hot start, the team faded fast, and the headlines became more about clicks than victories.
5. 2011 Penn State Nittany Lions
What began as a promising season turned into one of the darkest chapters in college football history. The off-field scandal rocked the program and overshadowed everything happening on Saturdays.
4. 2018 Florida State Seminoles
The transition to a new era under Willie Taggart was rocky from the start. With coaching questions, team drama, and lopsided losses, it felt like the Noles were in freefall.
3. 2007 Miami Hurricanes
The swagger was there, but the results weren’t. This team brought plenty of heat off the field but failed to deliver where it actually mattered.
Read more: Ranking the 10 Most Frustrating NFL Teams to Root For
2. 2016 Baylor Bears
A team clouded by scandal and program-wide dysfunction couldn’t escape the consequences. Even with talent on the field, the drama off of it made winning an afterthought.
Read more: Ranking the 15 NFL Teams That Could Totally Implode in 2025–26
1. 2003 Alabama Crimson Tide
Before the Saban dynasty, Alabama had a flair for dysfunction. A coaching carousel, probation issues, and underwhelming performances made for a season full of headlines—and not the good kind.
Read more: The 20 Greatest College Running Backs of All Time
