The 10 Most Clutch Field Goal Kickers in NFL History

Kickers play a crucial role in the NFL, often having the outcome of entire games and even championships resting on their ability to make field goals under immense pressure.

From record-breaking feats to clutch performances in the highest-stakes moments, the league has seen some incredible talent over the years. This article counts down the top 10 NFL kickers, celebrating their achievements and contributions to the game.

10. David Akers

David Akers, during his time with the 49ers, kicked a field goal from an impressive 63 yards out, matching the NFL record. He also holds the distinction of attempting more field goals in a single season than any other player in NFL history. Over his 16-year career in the NFL, Akers played for several teams, but his most notable contributions were with the Eagles and 49ers.

9. Jason Elam

Jason Elam, a standout NFL kicker, showcased his skills on the field for an impressive 17 seasons. He racked up nearly 2,000 points, proving his reliability with a field goal success rate of over 80%. In 2006, he etched his name in Denver Broncos history by setting a record for the most accurate season. Elam’s career spanned 15 years with the Broncos and a final 2 years with the Atlanta Falcons, before he hung up his cleats in 2010.

8. Gary Anderson

For over two decades, the NFL was graced by the exceptional talent of kicker Gary Anderson. His 23-season career, which concluded in 2004, was filled with remarkable achievements. Anderson’s scoring prowess was unmatched, amassing a staggering 2,434 points, a record-setting feat at the time of his retirement. His impressive performance also earned him the honor of being the top scorer in Pittsburgh Steelers’ history, contributing a whopping 1,343 points to the franchise.

The 1998 season stands as a testament to Anderson’s precision and consistency, as he flawlessly executed all of his 35 field goal attempts and 59 extra points. His career was not just long, but it was filled with extraordinary accomplishments that set him apart in the NFL.

7. Morten Andersen

Nicknamed “the Great Dane,” Morten Andersen showcased his exceptional skills as a kicker in the NFL for an impressive 25 seasons. His precision and power led to an astounding number of successful field goals, propelling his career points to sky-high levels. Andersen’s longevity in the game is unmatched, holding the NFL record for the most games played. His remarkable career was fittingly recognized in 2017 when he was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

6. Stephen Gostkowski

Stephen Gostkowski, a powerhouse in the NFL, has topped the league’s scoring charts five times. His record-breaking streak of consecutive extra points is a testament to his precision and consistency. With three Super Bowl victories under his belt as a Patriot, and four Pro Bowl selections, Gostkowski’s legacy is undeniable. His impressive 88.6% postseason field goal percentage showcases his reliability when the stakes are high.

5. Matt Prater

With a powerful kick that’s hard to match, Matt Prater has made his mark in the NFL. He’s shattered records, boasting an impressive 81 field goals of 50 yards or more. In 2023, he outdid himself, setting a new NFL record by nailing seven field goals of 55 yards or more in a single season.

Though he once held the record for the longest field goal with a 64-yard kick, this record has since been surpassed. Despite this, Prater’s exceptional kicking ability continues to impress and inspire.

4. Harrison Butker

Harrison Butker, the Kansas City Chiefs’ ace kicker, has a knack for nailing crucial kicks. In 2022, he blasted a record-breaking 62-yard field goal, the longest in his career. His golden moment came in Super Bowl LVII, where he delivered the decisive kick that clinched the victory.

Butker’s name is etched in the Chiefs’ record books multiple times, a testament to his exceptional skill. With three Super Bowl victories under his belt, his consistent and precise field goals have earned him a spot among the NFL’s elite kickers.

3. Chris Boswell

With a knack for nailing long-distance field goals, Chris Boswell has been a key player for the Pittsburgh Steelers since 2015. His precision, especially from 50 yards or more, is nothing short of impressive.

Boswell’s ability to deliver game-winning kicks under pressure has earned him a reputation as a reliable asset in crucial moments. His exceptional performance on the field has not only led to multiple Pro Bowl selections but also solidified his place as one of the Steelers’ most valuable players.

2. Justin Tucker

With a record-breaking 66-yard field goal under his belt, Justin Tucker is a force to be reckoned with in the NFL. His impressive career field goal percentage sits at a solid 89.1%, showcasing his consistent performance.

Tucker’s skills have earned him a spot in seven Pro Bowls and he’s been recognized as a first-team All-Pro five times. Despite a recent shift in the rankings, Tucker’s accuracy remains a standout in the league.

1. Adam Vinatieri

Adam Vinatieri, a titan in the NFL, showcased his prowess over an impressive 24-season career. He successfully booted nearly 600 field goals, a testament to his consistency and precision. His performance in five Super Bowl games was nothing short of spectacular, with a majority of his field goal attempts finding their mark.

Not to mention, he never missed an extra point. Vinatieri’s knack for delivering game-changing kicks in high-stakes situations, particularly Super Bowls, has etched his name in the annals of NFL history.