When discussing football greats, offense and defense tend to steal the spotlight, but special teams players are often the unsung heroes who can change the course of a game in an instant. Whether it’s a clutch field goal, a game-breaking kick return, or a perfect punt that flips field position, special teams play is vital to a team’s success.
This list highlights the top 15 special teams players of all time—kickers, punters, and return specialists—who made an undeniable impact on the game.
15. Brian Mitchell (Return Specialist)
One of the most consistent returners in NFL history, Brian Mitchell ranks second all-time in all-purpose yards (23,330). He was a threat on both kick and punt returns and helped lead Washington to a Super Bowl victory in the 1991 season.
14. Morten Andersen (Kicker)
A Hall of Fame kicker, Morten Andersen played 25 seasons and retired as the NFL’s all-time leading scorer (since surpassed). His longevity and clutch kicking made him one of the greatest ever.
13. Ray Guy (Punter)
The first pure punter inducted into the Hall of Fame, Ray Guy revolutionized the position. His hang time, directional punting, and ability to pin opponents deep made him a defensive weapon for the Raiders.
12. Adam Vinatieri (Kicker)
Known for his clutch performances, Adam Vinatieri hit some of the most famous kicks in NFL history, including game-winners in two Super Bowls for the Patriots. He is one of the highest-scoring players in league history.
11. Mel Gray (Return Specialist)
Mel Gray was one of the most electric returners of the 1990s, with six career return touchdowns and multiple All-Pro selections. His speed and elusiveness made him a nightmare for coverage units.
10. Johnny Hekker (Punter)
One of the best punters of the modern era, Johnny Hekker changed the way teams approached punting. His pinpoint accuracy and ability to execute trick plays made him a valuable asset for the Rams.
9. Jan Stenerud (Kicker)
The first kicker inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame, Stenerud was one of the pioneers of modern placekicking. He helped lead the Chiefs to a Super Bowl IV victory and was one of the first to employ a soccer-style kicking approach.
8. Devin Hester (Return Specialist)
Arguably the most feared returner in NFL history, Devin Hester holds the record for the most return touchdowns (20). His opening kickoff return touchdown in Super Bowl XLI is one of the most iconic plays in the sport’s history.
7. Steve Tasker (Special Teamer)
Considered one of the greatest gunners in NFL history, Steve Tasker was a force in coverage units for the Buffalo Bills. He was a seven-time Pro Bowler and a key contributor during Buffalo’s four Super Bowl appearances.
6. Justin Tucker (Kicker)
The most accurate kicker in NFL history, Justin Tucker has redefined what it means to be an elite kicker. His 66-yard game-winner in 2021 set an NFL record, and his consistency is unmatched.
5. Dante Hall (Return Specialist)
Nicknamed “The Human Joystick,” Dante Hall’s ability to change direction on a dime made him one of the most dangerous return men of all time. His highlight-reel plays for the Chiefs in the early 2000s are legendary.
4. Billy “White Shoes” Johnson (Return Specialist)
One of the first true return specialists, Johnson was known for his dazzling moves and signature touchdown dance. His impact on the return game helped shape special teams play for future generations.
3. Lou Groza (Kicker/Tackle)
A dual-threat as both a kicker and an offensive lineman, Lou Groza was one of the early greats of the game. His powerful leg and versatility earned him a Hall of Fame nod and made him one of the sport’s pioneers.
Related: Ranking Every Starting QB in the NFL – Who’s the Best of the Best?
2. Deion Sanders (Return Specialist/Cornerback)
While primarily known as a Hall of Fame cornerback, Deion Sanders was also a lethal returner. His blazing speed and playmaking ability made him a threat to score every time he touched the ball on special teams.
Related: 15 Former NFL Wide Receivers Who Could Still Play in Today’s Game
1. Gale Sayers (Return Specialist/Running Back)
Though his career was cut short, Gale Sayers was one of the most dynamic players to ever take the field. He averaged an astonishing 30.6 yards per kick return and scored six return touchdowns in just seven seasons. His ability to dominate in multiple facets of the game cements him as the greatest special teams player of all time.
Related: Ranking the 15 Most Loyal NFL Players of All Time
